Full menu with prices & pictures
Captain Arthur's 4451 Mahoning Ave, 44515, Youngstown...
+13307926764
Reserve a table now for Captain Arthur's
On this site, you can find the complete menu of Captain Arthur's from Youngstown. Currently, there are 2 courses and drinks available.
What Tammy likes about Captain Arthur's:
My husband and I drive over an hour to come here and eat. The owner is very nice and pleasant. Food is very good have had everything on the menu. Never have we had a bad meal from here. Grilled fish is the best I have had in years. The people who own this place really take pride in what they do and truly want to keep their customers happy. View all feedback.
What Angel Blaga doesn't like about Captain Arthur's:
As you can probably tell, this used to be an Arthur Treachers. They still serve up good fried food without the mustard yellow color scheme that some people may not like. But that 's what made Arthur Treachers so recognizable. Captain Arthurs needs a better outside sign to attract customers. It 's just plain white! I drove past this place for 2 months before I finally noticed it! View all feedback.
The people were very nice but the fish had no taste.
Clean orderly friendly fresh oil for fryers so no added taste or smell between fish other fried...
As you can probably tell, this used to be an Arthur Treachers. They still serve up good fried f...
The fish was too fishy, if that makes sense. Everything else, fries, coleslaw etc was good but...
The fish was under cooked an the chicken was over cooked so was the hush puppies i wasn't given...