Arthur Treacher's - Youngstown

Fish-chips, Fish, Fish And Chips

Arthur Treacher's

Arthur Treacher's
4.0 / 5 (1705 reviews)

Description

**Restaurant Review: A Taste of Nostalgia at Captain Treacher's**

Once home to Arthur Treacher's, Captain Treacher's delivers a delightful experience with a menu that honors the beloved fried classics. While the decor has shed the infamous mustard yellow, it lacks a striking exterior sign to catch the eye. Diners rave about the freshness and quality of the food, particularly the grilled fish, while some have faced inconsistencies in preparation. The restaurant maintains a clean and welcoming atmosphere, with friendly staff dedicated to customer satisfaction. For those in search of nostalgic flavors, Captain Treacher's promises a rewarding culinary journey that’s worth the visit.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Angel

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 1705 reviews
jakob49
25.11.2017

While the food is still reasonably good, the staff leave a lot to be desired.

clare34
25.11.2017

Get it while you can! This restaurant chain has largely gone out of business850 locations in the 1980'sFewer than 20 now.

davonte85
31.08.2022

The restaurant is no longer Arthur Treacher's - it is now Captain Treacher's. Despite the name change, the dining experience remains the same as Arthur Treacher's.

vblaga
08.09.2023

It's evident that this restaurant was once an Arthur Treacher's. They still serve fantastic fried food, but they've moved away from the mustard yellow color scheme that some might have found unappealing. That bright hue was actually part of what made Arthur Treacher's so distinctive. Captain Arthur's could really enhance its appeal with a more striking exterior sign to attract customers—right now, it's just a plain white sign! I drove past this place for two months before I even noticed it!

tammy-4
08.09.2023

My husband and I drive over an hour to come here and eat. The owner is very nice and pleasant. Food is very good have had everything on the menu. Never have we had a bad meal from here. Grilled fish is the best I have had in years. The people who own this place really take pride in what they do and truly want to keep their customers happy.

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.