Full menu with prices & pictures
The Milk Pail 1346 Montauk Hwy, 11976, Water Mill,...
+16315372565
Reserve a table now for The Milk Pail
A comprehensive menu of The Milk Pail from WATER MILL covering all 8 courses and drinks can be found here on the food list.
What User likes about The Milk Pail:
There is a wide variety of items on the menu, though they are a bit on the expensive side. I was hoping for more cheese options, but overall, my meal exceeded my expectations. View all feedback.
I visited a charming little market and purchased some delicious cheese, soppressa, and barbecue...
There is a wide variety of items on the menu, though they are a bit on the expensive side. I wa...
The food is fresh and delicious, but it is slightly pricier than expected.
I had the best pfirsich cake, so delicious soft cookies, and top-off with coffee smoothie.
Been going to the Milk Pail for 20 years. Jennifer knows us as the Gals who come on Sunday of C...