Sweet Tomato's - SHELTER ISLAND

The menu of Sweet Tomato's from SHELTER ISLAND includes 56 dishes. On average, dishes or drinks on the card cost about $18.7. The categories can be viewed on the menu below.

Located on Shelter Island, Sweet Tomato's Restaurant Bar offers fresh and contemporary Italian cuisine in a warm and inviting setting. Start your meal with the delicious sweet peas and Bolognese-filled fried arancini rice balls served with marinara, or try the calamari alla griglia topped with feta cheese, fresh herbs, seared artichokes, and Kalamata olives for a shared appetizer. Specialties on the menu include the chicken scarpariello, a half organic chicken marinated in red wine vinegar with sausage, lemon, rosemary, and roasted potatoes, as well as the vegetable risotto garnished with parsley. Indulge in pasta dishes like the 8-hour braised short ribs with homemade pappardelle, classic fettuccine Bolognese, or rigatoni della nonna with eggplant—all freshly made to order. For a delightful dining experience, sit outdoors on the lovely patio at Sweet Tomato's Restaurant Bar.