Full menu with prices & pictures
Sweet Tomato's 15 Grand Avenue, SHELTER ISLAND, Uni...
+16317494114
Reserve a table now for Sweet Tomato's
The Card of Sweet Tomato's from SHELTER ISLAND contains about 56 different dishes and drinks. On average, you pay for a dish / drink about $18.6.
Located on Shelter Island, Sweet Tomato's Restaurant Bar offers fresh and contemporary Italian cuisine in a warm and inviting setting. Start your meal with the delicious sweet peas and Bolognese-filled fried arancini rice balls served with marinara, or try the calamari alla griglia topped with feta cheese, fresh herbs, seared artichokes, and Kalamata olives for a shared appetizer. Specialties on the menu include the chicken scarpariello, a half organic chicken marinated in red wine vinegar with sausage, lemon, rosemary, and roasted potatoes, as well as the vegetable risotto garnished with parsley. Indulge in pasta dishes like the 8-hour braised short ribs with homemade pappardelle, classic fettuccine Bolognese, or rigatoni della nonna with eggplant—all freshly made to order. For a delightful dining experience, sit outdoors on the lovely patio at Sweet Tomato's Restaurant Bar.
Well. We just lost our favorite restaurant.... We LOVED Sweet Tomatoes and have been frequent v...
The special Cioppino came incomplete. Two ingredients were missing and no mention to the custom...
Three nights on Shelter Island and we stumbled upon Sweet Tomato's the first night. Despite the...
We were greatly disappointed from the last time we visited. Apparently the former owner and man...
The service was great but there seems to be a downgrade on food quality unlike in the past. Piz...
Chicken Scarpariello
half chicken w/ lemon, rosemary, peppers, red wine vinegar and roasted potatoes
Minestra Del Giorno
soup of the day
Insalata Di Granchio
jumbo crab meat, string beans, almonds, kalamata olives, tomato and citrus dressing
Trio De Bruschetta
Stracotto Di Manzo
our famous bone in braised beef short ribs with home made pappardelle