235 S Cayuga St Green St Garage - Newfield Hamlet

#12 - Pizza - Newfield Hamlet, #28 - Cafés - Newfield Hamlet, Casual
235S N Cayuga St, 14850, Ithaca, US, Newfield Hamlet, United States
Dishes: 35

235 S Cayuga St Green St Garage

3.8 / 5 of 69 Reviews
Phone
(+1)6078822333
Address
235S N Cayuga St, 14850, Ithaca, US, Newfield Hamlet, United States

Opening Hours

  • Tuesday
    17:00 -21:00
  • Wednesday
    17:00 -21:00
  • Thursday
    17:00 -21:00
  • Friday
    17:00 -21:00
  • Saturday
    17:00 -21:00
  • Sunday
    17:00 -21:00

Amenities

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 of 69 Reviews

What Wayne W likes about 235 S Cayuga St Green St Garage:
Definitely a higher end restaurant in the are, from the vibe to the food it is a higher class feel. For 5 of us the bill was well over 300$ with tip. But we did order some apps drinks and some food so it really leveled out. What I highly recommend is the past with meatballs and burrata. I can't remember the name of it lol. The burrata was fresh and the meatballs was fantastic beef and prosciutto mix. Recommend this p... View all feedback.

What Theano 12 doesn't like about 235 S Cayuga St Green St Garage:
This is definitely not the Cafe DeWitt of old. Since reopening under new ownership, the menu is super scaled back and food is very 'meh '. You really shouldn 't charge $15 for the tiniest sandwich imaginable, and not even bother to put so much as a handful of greens on the side. Also, we were confused by the slow service, since we were literally the only people ordering at the time. I am rooting for this place to do... View all feedback.

We started out at the bar, the bartender was great. Then on to our table. Our waiter was appare...

leisa-d

Pizza with butternut squash: needs less cheese. Takes over all the flavor. Makes it quite bland...

jack-b-office47

Truthfully, I had high expectations for this place- the ambience is absolutely gorgeous, and it...

lucia-l-elephant54

Good food, great drinks and a lovely atmosphere. Can be a bit on the pricey side but overall it...

tyler-d-bank26

My wife and I got married in September 2021. We had a lot of guests traveling in for the Saturd...

jp-g-ivy2588

Menu Items

More information

Related Restaurants

Fast & SimpleDownload Menu App now