Eagle - Himrod
Menu
On this site, you will find the complete menu of Eagle from Himrod. Currently, there are 14 dishes and drinks available.
Nestled in the Finger Lakes, this charming restaurant offers a vibrant atmosphere with friendly service, making it a popular destination for locals and visitors alike. Diners rave about the delicious beer-battered fish fry and savory soups, while others find satisfaction in classic comfort foods like hamburgers. Despite some concerns over timing and occasional meal inconsistencies, the warm hospitality and commitment to quality shine through. With an array of craft beers, ample outdoor seating, and a bustling environment, this eatery is increasingly recognized for its hearty meals and welcoming vibe, ensuring patrons leave with a memorable dining experience.
Images
Feedback
Was TJG at Eagle a mag?
Great local dining in an area of the Finger Lakes where food options can be limited. Small and quaint from the outside, with plenty of seating and bar space. Outdoor seating available. Delicious entrees and soups. One of the best beer-battered fish fries I've had and I try many. Light batter coating stays crisp. Excellent mushroom-sherry soup and New England clam chowder. Can get busy. Friendly staff. Parking out fro... View all feedback.
What Jonathan Evans dislikes about Eagle:
Our meal started off with our salads coming before our appetizer. Our shrimp appetizer was awful. I ordered a $30 Delmonico steak that was served to me raw they cooked me a second steak and serve that one raw as well. I finally paid my bill and left and I'm now going back to the cottage to cook my own dinner View all feedback.
Good food, nice clean place, staff was very attentive and thoughtful, and I believe it was the owner that came out and chatted with my wife and a couple times to make sure we were enjoying everything.
I ordered Chicken Parmesan which costs $22 and New England soup for $6 to take out, but I got a tiny quantity meal tiny chicken cutlet, 4 broccoli, smidgen noodles) and a tiny cup of soup, won't ever order anymore! ?
Great local dining in an area of the Finger Lakes where food options can be limited. Small and quaint from the outside, with plenty of seating and bar space. Outdoor seating available. Delicious entrees and soups. One of the best beer-battered fish fries I've had and I try many. Light batter coating stays crisp. Excellent mushroom-sherry soup and New England clam chowder. Can get busy. Friendly staff. Parking out front and across the street. Plenty of good beer and local wines on offer. No cell service inside, and very weak service outside.
Went for the first time on a Saturday for prime rib and was very disappointed. It definatly was not fresh. My wife ordered rare and I ordered mid rare. Neither was even close to what was ordered. Mine came grilled and was.more than well done. They replaced it but was actually cold on the bottom and the fat was still congealed and not even close to mid rare and inedible. To be fair they did not charge me for my meal but neither did my wife eat hers.
Full Menu
Sandwiches And Wraps
Himrod Ham$10.6Burger
Hot Pepper Bacon Burger$15.3Burgers & Sandwiches
Apple Butter Bbq Pulled Pork$11.8Scb Lunch Combo - Entree Options
Chicago Style Beef Sandwich$14.1From The Grill
Cajun Shrimp Sandwich$14.1Weekday Specials
Beer Burger$15.3
More information
QR-code link to the menu
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 3.9 / 5 (1327 reviews)Grill Coffee Sandwiches Breakfast Fish
Showboat
North Plum Point Road 3435, 14842 Himrod, US
- ★ 4.4 / 5 (1913 reviews)Farm-to-table Bar-lounge Full Wine
Sapalta
3482 Plum Point Rd S, Himrod, United States Of America
- ★ 4.7 / 5 (280 reviews)American Steak
Sapalta
3482 Plum Point Rd S, Himrod I-14842, United States