Buttermilk - City of New York

#22 - Order Cafés City of New York, #30 - Order Vegetarian City of New York, Coffee
260 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, City of New York, United States
Dishes: 64

Buttermilk

4.6 / 5 of 702 Reviews
Phone
+13479874004,+13479873941
Address
260 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, City of New York, United States

The eatery is also easily accessible by public transportation. The closest stop is MTA-Union St, which is 305 meters away, otherwise, there are places to park 268 meters away at 302-306 2nd St.

Opening Hours

  • Tuesday
    11:00-17:35
  • Wednesday
    11:00-17:35
  • Thursday
    11:00-17:35
  • Friday
    11:00-19:20
  • Saturday
    11:00-17:20
  • Sunday
    11:00-17:35

Reserve now

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 of 702 Reviews

What Madeleine Jordan likes about Buttermilk:
Love this place and pick up a small selection of baked goods from here about once a week! The chocolate cake in a jar is my absolute favorite. I also love getting the cake of the day slice, the cookies, and the bars. Had the raspberry pop-tart recently (pictured) and it was amazing! Have never had a bad experience in anyway here. View all feedback.

We’ve purchased all of our kids birthday cakes from a buttermilk. They are amazing! The cakes a...

stacey-337

Buttermilk Bakeshop made the cake for my baby shower and it was the highlight of the party. We...

johanna-185

We asked for a custom cake for our daughter's 1st birthday and shared a picture of what I was l...

sherrie-68

Great cakes, lovely staff. I have done multiple birthday cakes in the last couple of years. The...

asya-13

Love this place and pick up a small selection of baked goods from here about once a week! The c...

madeleine-45

Menu Items

  • Coffee

  • Homemade Desserts

    Buttermilk Pie

    Buttermilk Pie

  • Pastries & Cakes

    Cake Slice Of The Day

    Rotating flavor

  • Cakes

    Vanilla Mini Cake

    Serves 3-4 people

  • Dessert

    Whole Buttermilk Pie

    Custard based pie with brulee

  • This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients

More information

Related Restaurants

Fast & SimpleDownload Menu App now