Paulie's Kitchen Pizza - Yonkers

The guys working here (possibly the owner) were polite and the bacon, egg and cheese I got was maybe the best Ive had!

I've ordered here several times since they've opened and it's a very hit or miss place. Either the food will be GREAT or pretty bland/mediocre. Initially when I first discovered them (around their opening) they were AMAZING. Like they immediately became my go-to deli. As time has gone on, the quality has dwindled; Portions inconsistent, missing add-ons, not reading instructions. It's almost as if there's two cooks; one that actually cares and one that does the bare minimum and doesn't read or follow directions. I've literally tried almost the entire menu. The sandwiches and the pizza are the most consistent or at least relatively consistent. Breakfast Dinner are the unpredictable wild cards. You can order the same breakfast sandwich 3 times and you will get it in 3 different ways lol.

First time ordering from here. I got the chipotle chicken wrap and french fries. The wrap was delicious, the french fries were amazing and properly salted and they poked a hole in the cap to let the steam out during delivery so that they didn’t arrive soggy and gross… smartest people ever for doing that. The pizza looks really good in the pictures I’ll be definitely trying that next.

Paulie's Margherita pizza is the best. Not soggy. Nice crisp to it. Fresh ingredients. And the taste.... The best pizza in Yonkers.

So I ordered from here just yesterday and I ordered the chicken Parmesan sandwich and wings and fries. I must say it was so bad I couldn’t believe it. The rating and the food I got were completely the opposite it’s was so bad we were in shock. For starters the chicken parmesan aka the L’ITALA was rubbery and not a pesto insight the image on Uber eats is a complete lie which is disappointing because it looked like a proper meal to our demise the bread was soggy as if a drunk person put that god awful meal together straight from a freezer watery sauce and then sat on it. Then the wings I know can you believe someone could mess up wings, the wings it was crummy as if the batter it self was running away or it was fried in crummy oil and just bad tasting sauce tasting of grease with a hint of barbecue so disappointing. The bag itself leaking at the bottom with grease. The fries which was probably the best part soggy and cold at the tips as if they half fried the laziness for the best part of that god awful meal. I wouldn’t have fed that to my worst enemy. I would feel bad to give them the stomach ache I had after only a few bites . I lost my entire appetite from that never ever again .