Captain Tony's Pizza - Feedback

Very unique little spot. We drive OTR and try to find small non chain type places. Wasn't busy when we arrived. Cashier was taking a phone order but she acknowl... read more Very unique little spot. We drive OTR and try to find small non chain type places. Wasn't busy when we arrived. Cashier was taking a phone order but she acknowledged our presence. Prices are reasonable. Personal pan pizza plus one trip to salad bar wasplenty for me. Very tasty crust. Definitely will stop by again when we're in the area.

Had the lasagna and it was great, salad bar was stocked with a lot of items. read more Had the lasagna and it was great, salad bar was stocked with a lot of items.

The only downside I can mention about Captain Tony's Pizza is that I'm really missing their fantastic full buffet they offered before COVID altered everything.... read more The only downside I can mention about Captain Tony's Pizza is that I'm really missing their fantastic full buffet they offered before COVID altered everything. The staff is incredibly professional and friendly, and the food is consistently delicious. Although I'm getting takeout today instead of dining in, I've enjoyed many meals both in the restaurant and as takeout, and I've always been completely satisfied. I hope they bring back the full buffet soon! Today, I ordered the works: salad, pizza, garlic bread, and wings.

Wow! This place is amazing! For those who don’t know, that means they serve some delicious pizza with both hand-tossed and thin crust options! Plus, they have a... read more Wow! This place is amazing! For those who don’t know, that means they serve some delicious pizza with both hand-tossed and thin crust options! Plus, they have a retro arcade and pool tables that really bring back memories! And don’t forget to try the Sioux City soda to complete your meal. I’m definitely adding this spot to my list of favorite places to grab a bite to eat. Thanks, Captain Tony!

Absolutely amazing! Every time I’ve ordered, the pizza has been perfect. Whether I’m getting takeout or dining in, I’ve always been a satisfied customer. No mat... read more Absolutely amazing! Every time I’ve ordered, the pizza has been perfect. Whether I’m getting takeout or dining in, I’ve always been a satisfied customer. No matter which pizza I choose, the ingredients are fresh and it’s cooked just right. It’s never too greasy or too salty. Rae (not sure of the spelling) is always there with a friendly smile. Fantastic service!