Toasted Windermere

We shared two sandwiches: the Fig Goat and the Mac Attack. The Fig Goat was tasty and delicate, but the bread seemed either a bit undercooked or overstuffed, ma... read more We shared two sandwiches: the Fig Goat and the Mac Attack. The Fig Goat was tasty and delicate, but the bread seemed either a bit undercooked or overstuffed, making it hard to take a proper bite. This was disappointing because the goat cheese was wonderfully melty and smooth; I just wish the bread had a nice, light crispiness to enhance its flavor. On the contrary, the Mac Attack was fantastic! All the flavors melded beautifully, although it could have used a bit more bacon and arugula. Still, this didn’t detract from the overall experience. My only complaint was the sides that came with the sandwiches. I was hoping for something gooey and cheesy, but they didn’t quite deliver. The sandwiches themselves were somewhat thin and lacked those satisfying cheese-pull moments I was looking forward to. That said, the prices here are lower than many similar establishments in the area that offer unique grilled cheese options, which is definitely a consideration. You get what you pay for—lower prices often mean fewer fillings. Nonetheless, everything we tried was delicious. While I might not rush back solely for the grilled cheese, I’m definitely curious to try their burgers next time!

You can't go wrong with the grilled cheese! The portion size is perfect, and the fries are absolutely delicious. read more You can't go wrong with the grilled cheese! The portion size is perfect, and the fries are absolutely delicious.

The sandwiches here are absolutely fantastic, featuring amazing brisket and onions. When you add a side of perfectly crispy shoestring fries, you've got a truly... read more The sandwiches here are absolutely fantastic, featuring amazing brisket and onions. When you add a side of perfectly crispy shoestring fries, you've got a truly outstanding meal!

The food was generally mediocre. The mac and cheese had a burnt taste, but the buffalo chicken grilled cheese was surprisingly tasty, even though it wasn't exac... read more The food was generally mediocre. The mac and cheese had a burnt taste, but the buffalo chicken grilled cheese was surprisingly tasty, even though it wasn't exactly what I had anticipated.

I think it would be beneficial to offer a variety of vegan patties and allow customization by removing specific ingredients. read more I think it would be beneficial to offer a variety of vegan patties and allow customization by removing specific ingredients.