Magnottas Pizzeria - White Plains

The pizza is great for the exit and I love eating in the restaurant. I love the cold cuts and breads that they give you. Serving sizes are especially large in their pasta dishes. Waitress is super nice and accommodating.

I just hate them going out of business. I was born and raised in White Plains NY. I bought so many pizzas from Magnottas, I could own that. I lived over the street when they opened the doors. I'm living in Alabama now, and I'm trying to get back to White Plains so I can visit my favorite pizza place, but it looks like they're not in operation when I get to Westchester. If I could only come back to Magnotta before they close. They were the best, are the best and will always keep the title as the best, even if they are closed. Angelo takes care of it, we really enjoyed your food.

If I had a pizzeria in my neighborhood, it would be Magnottas. I love Angelo, his pizza and his legacy. They are beautiful Italian Americans. Great bang for the buck here I love all kinds of pizza from Neapolitan to NY to Chicago to Detroit to CA Fusion style. This is classic NY Italian pizza. There are these little wombs in the taste buds of finer points of sauce. Crust is perfect for me. It's in balance. 5 of the 9 current photos are mine and I haven't been there for a year. Angelo always remembers me and greets me, but I come for his. My great brother lives near, first in Scarsdale (for schools) now in White Plains. When we went to visit, we stopped on the way to the cake and on the way to the other. All the time, even holidays. As I said at the price performance, feed the family type of place I want Magnattas in my neighborhood. Friday night, get a cake for the kids who take what I call the main bite. Pizza has half a life. Directly out of the oven, just when you are at the edge of burning the mouth. This is the best bite pizza control (I have to finish the disk).

The restaurant truly caters to families, and the owner is friendly, entertaining, and even takes on the role of cashier. The garlic knots are the best I've ever tasted, but the brownie? It’s absolutely amazing!

This is hands down the best grandma slice I've ever had! I highly recommend trying all the different pizza slices they offer. If you're looking for an incredible pizza along with some entertaining banter from the owners (who are true old-school Italians), you need to call or rush to this place right away. I absolutely love coming here!