Casey's - Wheatfield

Breakfast, Lunch, American

Casey's

Casey's
2.9 / 5 (215 reviews)

Description

Casey's in Wheatfield, IN, is a beloved American restaurant with a welcoming atmosphere and an average rating of 3.6 stars. Open from 4:00 AM to 11:00 PM, it's a great spot to satisfy any craving, with a diverse menu that includes delicious vegetarian options. Looking to plan your visit? Feel free to call ahead at (219) 956-3022 to check on wait times or reserve a table. If you're in the mood for something similar, don't forget to explore the offerings at Quiznos and Hop Quest Brewing Company. We’d love to hear about your favorite dishes, so be sure to leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Ingrid

Feedback

★ 2.9 / 5 from 215 reviews
julianna-h-2
19.12.2023

I ordered dinner for myself and my boyfriend since we hadn’t eaten yet. We got a pizza, breadsticks, and mac and cheese. My boyfriend went in to pick it up when it was supposed to be ready, but they hadn't even started making it. It would be understandable if they were busy, but they weren’t at all. So what was supposed to be a 30-minute wait has now turned into 50 minutes.

alaina-carter-1
19.12.2023

Amazing service even when they had over 14 orders at night time!!!!!

james-ahrendt-ii
19.12.2023

Everything is so overpriced and the ladies are pretty helpful but when you have more than three or four people in line someone should come out and help open another register causes people to be late to work

williams-ingrid
27.04.2025

Got to the store when they said it would be done and waited another 30 minutes for our pizza and sides. The girl up front was very nice but one of the guys supposed to be working/cooking was literally just standing back there talking. Very ridiculous.Several other people were waiting forever too.

jrunolfsdottir-3
27.04.2025

I come here all the time every time I order pizza they tell me 30-35 mins which is long as it is and it usually ends up being 45-50mins. Always show up when they say it will be done and it's never done in time.......updating review 6 months later addingthis part decided to try them again ordered a large pepperoni and 12 wings the guy on phone told me that was a size order Icould get them when they ring me out the lady behind register says they only do 8 or 16 which do I want I said I wanted the 12 Iordered she wouldn't let me have that option even tho the guy taking order told me that was a size so I had to choose 8 shecouldn't have just charged me somewhere in between or given them to me for their mistake......I am definitely done with thislocation.

FAQ

You can use the WLAN of the place free of charge.

The diner is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physical disabilities.

You can also pay for your dishes with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.