Italian Grille, Teays Valley

Did an online order. The earliest pick up time was an 1 hour. So I went through with it assuming they were busy since it was a Friday evening. Arrived at the expected time and to my surprise there were only two tables occupied. Got my food and it felt like it was sitting a awhile. The pizza crust was doughy and the side of Alfredo sauce we ordered was clumpy as if it was old and or expired. Alfredo sauce is NOT suppose to be clumpy! I don't know why it has mostly positive reviews but it's a huge … – show

I have been visiting this restaurant off and on for years, and watched it transform from what felt like an Italian themed diner into a full fledged Italian restaurant. The atmosphere inside is great and sets the tone for a fantastic meal. Unfortunately, the food doesn't quite live up to expectations. Portions are very large, however many of their flavors are not typical of what you would expect from an Italian restaurant in this price range. Alfredo sauce is a very simple sauce to make, howe … – show

This is by far the worst restaurant we have been. Our family has been to many Italian restaurants within outside the US. The food was just bland — nothing had a flavor. The Mariana sauce had so much acidity that I couldn’t even proceed after the first bite. The place also looks like a mix of the restore store (nothing against it), my great grandma’s house, and an escape room lol. It’s just a horrible experience. I’m sorry but there is no way we are coming back. The only good thing was our wai … – show

Service was fine. Food was amazing! We stop in this area about 6 times a year and finally found a place for a good meal. Everything is homemade....bread, dressing, noodles, sauces, etc. I look forward to visiting again soon.

The decor and dish ware are both relatively dated. The food is good, although the garlic bread has a sort of fishy taste to it.