Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What peter g Lombardozzi likes about Mike's Apizza:
Best brocoli Rabe pizza in the state,hands down even counting the big 3 in New haven,the crust , etc everything is flavorful and Mike's been consistent for 30 plus years,try it you won't be disappointed View all feedback.
What B Noble doesn't like about Mike's Apizza:
I really wanted to like this place but it was a big disappointment. The pizza crust was light and crispy that was the positive. The sauce and meatball lacked any flavor at all. Unfortunately the same with the soup. I found myself adding tons of pepper to the pizza and salt to the soup. I also get this place has been around for a while but it doesn’t excuse the filth. It all made me question the sanitation standards i... View all feedback.
It is really good try it ,it would put you in mind of MODERN PIZZA in New Haven,
Best brocoli Rabe pizza in the state,hands down even counting the big 3 in New haven,the crust , etc everything is flavorful and Mike's been consistent for 30 plus years,try it you won't be disappointed
Very delicious pizza not greasy, not salty, not too much spicy, just the right mild taste when you can feel the ingredients! The calzone was amazing with excellent ricotta! It was our first visit and we were pleasantly surprised by the quality food.
I really wanted to love this place. It’s fine being a little old neighbor pizza place but with that I would think the quality would be good. We all said that we have never seen such skimpy toppings. Couldn’t see the “meatballs” of any sort or fashion. Tiny tidbits were underneath the other scrapes of onions and peppers. At $4.50 per topping anyone would expect something that you could taste or distinguish as the item. It wasn’t cheap or fast which is fine if it’s a fair amount. We ended up buying more food afterwards. Didn’t want to buy more pizza being it takes long and was so skimpy for the not cheap price. We liked the taste though of what little there was.
Easily my favorite pizza in West Haven. There used to be so many contenders but they’ve all fallen to the wayside while Mike’s has stayed consistent. The house salad is so simple but that in house made Italian dressing is killer. I’d go just for the salad. Might ask them to add some cucumbers next time though.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
