Michaleno's Pizzeria - Feedback

Great service, great location, I only have 10 inches, so must be for real Italian pizza? test, with order of a S.M.O read more Great service, great location, I only have 10 inches, so must be for real Italian pizza? test, with order of a S.M.O

Small pizza place in West Bend. They have great pizza, I have never been disappointed. Staff is friendly and always helpful. read more Small pizza place in West Bend. They have great pizza, I have never been disappointed. Staff is friendly and always helpful.

Was in the area and felt like pizza, this was one of the few places I found that had dine in. Service was great and friendly. Garlic bread was very good. Pizza... read more Was in the area and felt like pizza, this was one of the few places I found that had dine in. Service was great and friendly. Garlic bread was very good. Pizza was good as well. Would go back if in the area again.

Excellent pizza the best and the crust is super good I ordered for the second time and it won’t be my last read more Excellent pizza the best and the crust is super good I ordered for the second time and it won’t be my last

I grew up outside NYC with a lot of great Italian restaurants and pizzerias. This place would close down there. There was no flavor in the sauce or crust. The s... read more I grew up outside NYC with a lot of great Italian restaurants and pizzerias. This place would close down there. There was no flavor in the sauce or crust. The sauce was more like tomato sauce rather than pizza or spaghetti sauce. I also had a calzone. Same bland flavor. Also VERY little ingredients inside. I would actually have preferred a Palermo thin crust pizza and a Hot Pocket. Would have been a hell of a lot cheaper too.

I've never had a bad meal here, and every order I've placed has exceeded my expectations. I've traveled extensively—from New York City to Italy, LA, and even Al... read more I've never had a bad meal here, and every order I've placed has exceeded my expectations. I've traveled extensively—from New York City to Italy, LA, and even Alaska. While I find New York City pizza to be just average—sort of floppy but crisp enough—everyone has their own tastes, which is part of the joy of exploring new places and trying different cuisines. At this restaurant, I can quickly grab a bacon cheeseburger, a pizza, a fish dinner, a chicken dinner, and lasagna all in one go, catering to the diverse appetites of six different people. It's unbeatable! And don’t forget to try the ribs; they are absolutely mouthwatering!

I was disappointed with the pizza. The crust was like cardboard, and the cheese lacked flavor. The sausage didn't stand out either. I’m not sure how they earned... read more I was disappointed with the pizza. The crust was like cardboard, and the cheese lacked flavor. The sausage didn't stand out either. I’m not sure how they earned the title of "best pizza" in West Bend. On a positive note, the staff was friendly and welcoming. I guess I'm just accustomed to the authentic pizzas from Italian restaurants and pizzerias on the east side of Milwaukee, like Momma Mia's.