Addy Mae's - West Bend

#15 - Seafood - West Bend, Ice Cream, Coffee

Addy Mae's

Addy Mae's
4.0 / 5 (49 reviews)

Description

Located in West Bend, this charming eatery offers a mixed bag of experiences. While the breakfast waffle combo and Sweet Porker Panini have garnered praise for their taste and quality, the service leaves much to be desired. Guests have noted long wait times and unhelpful staff, particularly a casual figure associated with ownership. Although the ice cream is misleadingly marketed as traditional, the smoothies have received positive feedback. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for lunch, but diners are advised to snag more cupcakes—taking some to go could leave you wishing for more flavors.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Scott

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 49 reviews
debbie-garman-r
20.12.2023

The sandwiches were awesome and the cupcakes were fantastic!! Love this place!!! Highly recommend!

ev-dodd-w
20.12.2023

Great food my Reuben was fantastic! I am looking forward to the Ice Cream season again, too :

kim-m-restaurant0
20.12.2023

First time I ever ate there was today. Absolutely loved it. Had the seafood croissant and a bacon cupcake that was AMAZING!! Wish I would of bought a...

scott-degeneffe
18.02.2024

The woman who appeared to be the owner of the restaurant, dressed in yoga pants and having a relaxed attitude, wasn’t very helpful. We had to wait a long time, and the ice cream was only average. Overall, the service was pretty disappointing.

stan-winkowitsch-1
18.02.2024

The service was excellent, and it was wonderful to unwind in the cool air conditioning after our visit to the Grotto.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.