Infinity Diner - West Babylon
Infinity Diner
Menu
A comprehensive menu of Infinity Diner from West Babylon featuring all 106 menus and drinks can be found here on the list.
The restaurant has recently undergone new ownership, with mixed reviews from customers. Some guests have expressed disappointment in the decline in food quality, lack of attention to detail, and changes in menu offerings. However, others have praised the family-friendly atmosphere, attentive staff, generous portions, and reasonable prices. The restaurant seems to have both loyal customers who appreciate the cozy vibe and new customers who enjoy the hearty meals and friendly service. Overall, it appears that the reviews are divided between those who have noticed a decline in quality under new ownership and those who continue to have positive experiences at this established diner.
Images
Feedback
Was K at Infinity Diner a mag?
Great family experience. The host was amazing and attentive to my little ones and gave my family a great experience. The atmosphere is friendly and mellow, classic diner feel with the music and sitting. Food was spot on, and the prices are great. Would recommend it to anyone. Will be my go-to spot for a quick family sit and eat. View all feedback.
What Sarah K dislikes about Infinity Diner:
Disappointed I am even leaving this review but maybe the new owners will read this and take charge. I've been coming here for a while and always loved it, but since the new ownership the food has drastically gone downhill I understand this is a diner but the quality is below average for an above average price. No utensils given with take out anymore, no crackers for soup. The chicken I ordered was practically inedibl... View all feedback.
Its the usual diner. Been around for a long time. Good food and service. Family atmosphere.
Great family experience. The host was amazing and attentive to my little ones and gave my family a great experience. The atmosphere is friendly and mellow, classic diner feel with the music and sitting. Food was spot on, and the prices are great. Would recommend it to anyone. Will be my go-to spot for a quick family sit and eat.
I did not realize that it is a new owner but the service is as great. Always a pleasant visit. We always enjoy the food. The price is also great.
One of the best diners I have ever been to!!! They gave us a pasta salad for free as an appetizer and it was delicious I tell you! The right amount of zing healthy and fresh! The carrots in it were delicious with just the right amount of crunch! Our waitress was a fairy godmother type of a woman. She definitely deserves a raise as she enticed me to add fries to my order! My curly fries were cooked perfectly and tasted delicious and savoury. Oh and the burger I ordered was the Soho mushroom burger. It was the most delicious and juicy burger I have ever tasted and this is not an exaggeration! Owner if you see this review can you please tell me your secret! Super yummy coffee, very fresh lettuce, tomato and cole slaw with great service Coffee and soda refills kept coming!
This is a so so diner. Some of the food was good, some was completely inedible. The service was slow, but it was very busy. We had: Turkey Burger good Chocolate Chip Pancakes good Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap so so Chicken Souvlaki Pita inedible. The chicken was reheated and had a gelatinous chewy consistency. It also needed a ton of salt. Next time we are in Long Island, I don't think we will eat here.
Full Menu
Served On A Bagel Or Roll
Bagel With Lox & Cream CheeseButtermilk Pancakes
Buttermilk Pancakes With Fresh Strawberries (In Season)Breakfast Specials
Chocolate Chip Pancakes (3) With Two Scoops Of Ice Cream And Whipped Cream
Pumpkin Pancakes (In Season)Belgian Waffles
Belgian Waffles With Strawberry Preserves, Apple Preserves Or Blueberry PreservesSilver Dollar Pancakes (Mini)
Silver Dollar Pancakes (Mini)
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 3.4 / 5 (630 reviews)Chinese Sushi Soup Chicken AsianMushroom Chinese Japanese
779 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, United States Of America, 11704
"Staff is super friendly and food is excellent. Never feel"
★ 4.8 / 5 (222 reviews)Barbecue Bbq Cheese Noodles RibsBitterman's Bbq
Farmingdale Road, West Babylon, 11704, United States Of America
"I ordered the baby back ribs, baked beans, and mac and cheese. Unfortunately, I wasn't impressed with the baked beans or the mac and cheese. The ribs..."
★ 4.9 / 5 (63 reviews)#5 Pizza in West Babylon ItalianPizza King
Straight Path, West Babylon, 11704, United States Of America
"Great Lasagna can’t wait to order it again"