A Nice Cream Stop - WELLFLEET

Ice Cream, Coffee, Fish
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

A Nice Cream Stop

A Nice Cream Stop
4.6 / 5 (613 reviews)

Menu

On this website, you will find the complete menu of A Nice Cream Stop from WELLFLEET. Currently, there are 24 dishes and drinks available.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Stephen

Images

A Nice Cream Stop Outside A Nice Cream Stop Inside A Nice Cream Stop Menu A Nice Cream Stop Food

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 613 reviews

Was V S at A Nice Cream Stop a mag?
Great place for ice cream lots of flavors. I've been to all the ice cream places in Wellfleet multiple times. If I had to rank the top three I would put Emacks at #2 Pj's at #3 and Gelato Joy at #1 because they are the only one to make theirs in house and daily from what i understand. I would not hesitate to go to any of the 3. View all feedback.

justin-shatraw
17.12.2023

Good news: emack bolios ice cream is the best. bad news: $35 for four ice creams and three of them were single scoop.

kyle-douglas-2
17.12.2023

Cash only but good ice-cream for sure. Worth the trip.

doug-campbell-2
17.12.2023

I loved the salted caramel chocolate pretzel flavor! It was delicious.

stephen-sutton-vine4
17.12.2023

Very good ice cream!!!

j-h-student6
17.12.2023

On our annual vacation ice cream tour in the Cape, we always try at least 1 or 2 places we haven 't been to before, and A Nice Cream Stop was on this year 's list. The good: staff is very friendly! Cozy outside sitting area and the town is a nice place to walk and enjoy the ice cream. The bad: Extremely disappointed in the ice cream itself. I bought Cookie Dough and immediately noticed that it was bland. Very, very bland. The dough and chocolate chips were fine, but the ice cream tasted milky, not creamy and definitely not rich. At $7 for a *small* cone ! which was far higher than any other place we 'd visited it was a disappointment overall. To see if I was crazy, I immediately went down to Mac 's on the Pier and tried a sample of the same flavor. The difference was immediate THAT was excellent ice cream. The burst of flavor from even the small sample said it all. And Mac 's was $2 less, which is much more in line with competitors. But really, there was no competition. In reading other reviews, it appears that comments about bland vanilla based ice creams are not uncommon, as are comments about how freakin ' expensive the stuff is. Gave an extra star because the staff was nice, but this is really all about the ice cream, right? No question that we will not return.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.