Cosmo Bella Pizza Catering - Wayne

Don't judge a book by its cover when it comes to this unassuming pizza place. Head inside to their dining room (where you can bring your own bottle) which is open Wednesday to Sunday from 5 pm onwards. Our first visit was a pleasant surprise and we will definitely be returning. Carmine and Michele were gracious hosts and made us feel right at home. They have been there for a while, so we regret not discovering them sooner. Their dining room has recently been renovated and is tastefully decorated, with the music of Sinatra softly playing in the background. I tried The Veal ala Clark and it was absolutely delicious, especially the sauce. My wife opted for the 3 Amici (a mix of shrimp, chicken, and sausage) which she thoroughly enjoyed. We will definitely be back to sample more of their menu - what a gem of a find!

We dined in the new dining room last night. The atmosphere felt as cozy as being in your own home. Italian music played softly in the background. The decor was lovely. The Italian food was delicious, the best we've had in a long time. Thank you so much, we now have a new favorite spot to eat.

Cosmo Bella is my go-to spot for all things Italian, especially pizza! It is a beloved establishment in Pequannock, and I couldn't imagine a better place than Cosmo's. The owners, Michelle and Carmine, are incredibly welcoming and treat their guests like family. Bring your own bottle and savor a delicious meal at Carmine's Trattoria, where you can truly feel the family atmosphere that the owners embody. Bon appétit!

Wandered into this pizzeria and found a gem of a restaurant! Family owned and operated, specials to die for and feel we are a part of THEIR family! Cozy dining room and you are made to feel that you are eating at their home! Highly recommend!

Loves this restaurant! my father has been there since they opened up and brought me as a child, and I always have to be in the place where I have to go to get a cheesecake!