Fred's Pizza - Waverly

#6 - Pizza - Waverly, American, Vegetarian Friendly

Fred's Pizza

Fred's Pizza
4.2 / 5 (9529 reviews)

Description

A beloved Waverly pizza spot praised for fresh ingredients, standout specialty pies (Moonshine BBQ) and warm, attentive service — even memorable birthday hospitality. Regulars laud delivery and occasional buffet nights, plus solid sides like mexi-stix and garlic knots. However, experiences vary: some find pizzas greasy, toppings skimpy, and flavors inconsistent. Price feels high to some customers, and recent policy changes — swapped fresh mushrooms for canned, limited buffet/salad-bar availability, and no complimentary tap water — have left patrons disappointed.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Keith

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 9529 reviews
keith-steiner
04.10.2024

Normally, we enjoy driving to Waverly just for Fred's pizza. Today, it was not at all like it usually is. Was the sauce changed? And the tea is usually great! Not today....may not be back.

shaun-stephens-2
04.10.2024

Omg that 26 pizza is huge!!

mike-butcher-3
04.10.2024

The food is okay, definitely not worth the premium price they charge. We bought the pepperoni supreme, and we we're lucky to get 2 pepperonis on a slice of pizza. Overall food taste good, but they really skimp out on the toppings. Not worth the cost to me.

zack-clayton-1
04.10.2024

A must stop in Waverly when going south on 23 on return. Parking: Spaces reserved in front of store in the plaza shopping center, 20 or so spaces.

jennifer-erin-weed01
04.10.2024

Addicted to the Moonshine BBQ Chicken. The mexi-stix is and garlic knots are great! The breadsticks with cheese are mediocre. Love how they offer a fresh side salad for $5. What I don’t like, is that you can’t just get a complimentary cup of water. It’s either pay for bottled water or a fountain drink.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.