Reviews
What Tim Meuter doesn't like about Balistreri's Italian-american:
You want mediocre greasy food, ok service, a long wait, and cramped seating, then this is the place for you. This used to be a go-to restaurant for my family for gatherings and when folks were visiting, but we are officially done. Not sure if the place went downhill or if we just realized it was never that good to begin with. Either way, there are much better places to spend your money. 2 stars instead of 1 because i... View all feedback. What Diane Howe likes about Balistreri's Italian-american:
We had eggplant and pizza. Both were very good! The amount of eggplant was huge for 2 of us. Half an order would've been plenty. The pizza was probably the best I've had in 5 years. Lots of sausage! We went at 2:00 pm. It was crazy busy, but our waitress was on top of everything, and our food came out fairly quickly and was hot and delicious. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
By far the best pizza that I have had anywhere in the US. I always stop here whenever I visit Wisconsin
I was quickly seated and had a really great server that was very polite and to the point. Also, he helped out on the menu. Which was big on the points! I'm not...
read moreUpon entering the establishment, we were welcomed with a clean and pleasant atmosphere. We started with an order of some fantastic cheese sticks while we waited...
read moreLove this place. Just came back here for the first time in about a year for lunch, I missed it!
Great pizza, great eggplant fries, great service... this place is a classic Milwaukee pizza place! You can't go wrong ordering pizza here!!!