Overtyme Grille Tap Room - Waterford

The rodeo nachos were disappointing. The pork was tough and dry, making it hard to enjoy. The nachos themselves were also dry, and they simply topped them with canned black beans. The coleslaw was quite unappetizing; it had a smell reminiscent of pool water, and the waitress mentioned that there had been complaints about it all day. I don’t understand why they would still serve it under those circumstances. However, I will say the waitress was very friendly and apologized for the experience, though she was clearly overwhelmed being the only one on duty. Overall, I left feeling quite let down.

I went to check out the line dancing and ended up staying for dinner. I ordered salads, which were decent and tasty. The service was good overall. The line dancing was popular, with many regulars who already knew the songs, so we didn't get much of a chance to join in, but it was still a lot of fun. The venue itself is quite large, and we even danced in the banquet hall since it wasn’t being used at the time. There’s also an arcade with bowling lanes, which is great for kids, and plenty of sports TVs around. The food prices were reasonable, while the drinks were priced about average. Overall, it was a good experience!

We were in a room for a private party. It was spacious, clean and had its own restrooms. The wait staff were attentive and friendly. The food was good and restocked constantly. Highly recommend for a private party.

However, the service can be inconsistent and a bit distant. It’s hard to tell if the staff genuinely doesn’t notice us or if they just don’t want to engage. The staff seems to change frequently, and they often appear too busy behind the counter to engage with customers. This can be a real issue for newcomers. Regulars may find new places to socialize, but as long-time locals, we notice the lack of attention to service. I think there needs to be more training for some of the staff, especially during the evening, so they can focus more on welcoming customers rather than just socializing among themselves. There's a certain vibe of entitlement that this place is the go-to spot, which can be quite off-putting to anyone paying attention. While we do enjoy coming here occasionally, the feeling of being an inconvenience to the staff, who are supposed to be there to serve, is becoming a bit tiresome.

We got married and had a reception for 75 people here just a few weeks ago. First of all, the owner, Boomer and his wife are genuinely kind people. They definitely went above and beyond to make our day special and to make it happen at a reasonable price! They helped make set up happen and genuinely took interest in any visions I had, we’re very accommodating, and helped us find a DJ who ROCKED and had everyone out on the dance floor all night! The staff was attentive. The bartenders were awesome. We opted for the pizza buffet bc we both love a good pizza and overtyme has great pizza! It was delicious. My only complaint for the entire evening is we did run out of pizza rather quickly. It was a little bit of a bummer. However, there was plenty of salad, breadsticks, and pasta. Only noting here to advise going a different route for food if you have more than 50 60 people. There were other events going in the bar that also involved pizza so I don’t think the pizza ovens could make it all happen… we did get lots of compliments on the food choice and taste it was a hit. Overall, We genuinely had an incredible day and I think everyone else enjoyed themselves too! We look forward to coming back often to enjoy a meal and their company too!