Pizza Guy - Wales

Italian, Delivery Services, Pizza
Reservation
Reservation request for Pizza Guy.

Pizza Guy

Pizza Guy
4.4 / 5 (1192 reviews)

Description

Pizza Guy, located in Wales, WI, is a beloved Italian restaurant known for its inviting atmosphere and outstanding menu, boasting an impressive average rating of 4.2 stars. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, we invite you to reserve a table by calling (262) 968-4900, whether you're enjoying a romantic dinner for two or celebrating with a larger group. Our menu features a delightful selection of diet-conscious dishes, including vegetarian options, ensuring there's something for everyone. Experience the cozy ambiance that makes Pizza Guy a favorite spot for locals. Have you visited us before? We’d love to hear your feedback with a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Hannah

Reservation request for Pizza Guy

Submit Reservation Request

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 1192 reviews
hannah-jonas-2
17.05.2025

This is some of the best pizza and service I have recieved in a while. Every part of this pizza is loaded with freshness and flavor. Half the battle is crust and it is perfectly crispy and the perfect thickness in comparison to sauce and cheese. Lots ofsauce and cheese(! , just as a pizza should be. Once I started, I couldn't stop eating it. Thanks to the wonderful people whoprepared this pizza and the kindness of the staff. This is my go to pizza spot now :

s-m-smacks-elephant8
17.05.2025

First time here and it was well worth it. Pizza (BBQ chicken and Sausage/mush) were delicious. Great tasting hand tossed crust, flavorful sauce and the right amount of toppings and cheese. We also had some cheese bread which was good too. Theyalso have a reward system via mobile phone to get some credits and discounts on future purchases. $1 1 point $25/credit at250 points. We will certainly be back and wish we hadn?t taken so long to finally try it after driving by for so many years. Ithink I?ve found our ?Go To? pizza place!

deb-bialozynski
12.08.2024

Ordered a pizza and garden salad to go tonight they are both amazing!! I walked in and was greeted in a friendly prompt manner!! Our cauliflour crust pizza is delicious, along with the huge fresh salad. Kuddos to the pizza maker!! The salad is loaded with tomatoes, mushrooms, black olives, green pepper, onions! Can't wait to go back real soon!! Lastly, their customer service is over the top...after I placed my order over the phone I received a call back from the young man just to go over my order to make sure everything is right (I really appreciated that)!!

teri-roscoe-1
17.08.2024

Always delivered hot and on time Dietary restrictions: gluten free crust is so yummy!

corey-meaney-office5
12.08.2024

Been loving the pepperoni stuffed bread sticks from here. They are tasty and a decent deal for the amount you get. Overall food is good and definitely recommend carryout considering the size of the restaurant and the cost before delivery already being pretty high.

FAQ

You can also enjoy gluten-free meals at the place.

The restaurant accepts various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.