Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.1 out of 5
Impressive | 945 reviews

What User doesn't like about Stefano's Pizzeria:
We order from there quite a bit.. The last two orders the calzones has been correct the first time I said nothing The second time I called up they made a big to do out of it said I had to bring the other one back for proof as I told them it had stuff in it that I didn't order.. no problem we brought it back only for them to inspect it in front of us saying well there was only a little bit of bacon in there in certain... View all feedback. What User likes about Stefano's Pizzeria:
Last night we had a little wedding reception for our daughter and new son-in-law. The food was amazing! The staff was absolutely wonderful and it was a perfect venue!! Our waitress was great, she was attentive to our needs and had a great since humor. Very recommended! And thanks for making the evening so special. Honestly the Tuttles View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Menu
4.2 ★ from 8 reviews

Great family story! We had sicilian pepperoni with jalapeno peppers and it was huge... 16 pieces. Pizza and garlic bread were fantastic, service was fast and fr...

read more

$80 dollar order, food was cold, they forgot my sauce, and I'm glad I paid $7 for it.

Last night we had a little wedding reception for our daughter and new son-in-law. The food was amazing! The staff was absolutely wonderful and it was a perfect...

read more

I enjoy Stefano's pizza since they opened in Carthage in 1985 and still today, although I don't live there anymore, I still make it a point to stop and enjoy so...

read more

Always happy to eat here. Great portions. Good ingredients. Pizza reminds me of NYC. I'll be in Carthage a few days a month. That's the only place I feel like e...

read more
Yelp
3.5 ★ from 71 reviews
Gary
11.11.2023 - 14:26

My wife and I began our meal with the Garlic Knots. She ordered a cheese pizza, which was quite delicious, while I opted for a calzone filled with pepperoni, sa...

read more
Samuel
11.11.2023 - 14:26

I've been dining here for several years, and I've never had a dish that wasn't delicious! The pizza and calzones are consistently fantastic, along with everythi...

read more
Endercake
11.11.2023 - 14:26

You have to try the garlic knots—they're life-changing! I absolutely love this restaurant; the food is amazing!

Menupix
4.2 ★ from 15 reviews
Restaurantji
4.0 ★ from 214 reviews
Sirved
4.2 ★ from 644 reviews
Restaurants
4.0 ★ from 1 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Village of Carthage

4.4
Menu
Open Now
4.4
Menu
Open Now
City: Watertown (near Village of Carthage), 259 Eastern Blvd, Watertown, United States
"My favorite place to go. Each time I go to Watertown first stop"
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Watertown (near Village of Carthage), 1857 State St, 13601, Watertown, US, United States
"Went there for the shrimp pad Thai it’s the best ever!"
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Evans Mills (near Village of Carthage), 26121 Us Route 11, Evans Mills, NY 13637, Evans Mills, United States Of America, 28334
"10 out of 10 amazing tastes so good, best sushi here."
4.2
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.2
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Harrisburg (near Village of Carthage), 5445 State Highway 12, Town Of Harrisburg, 28075, United States Of America
"Love the pickle juice slushie!"
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Carthage (near Village of Carthage), 323 State St, 13619, Carthage, United States
"Good food, good price, very nice people"
4.1
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.1
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Carthage (near Village of Carthage), 25044 County Route 47, Carthage, United States
"Atmosphere: 5"
4.2
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.2
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Evans Mills (near Village of Carthage), 8497 South Main Street Evans Mills, NY 13637, United States
"Great service and great atmosphere the blt I had was delicious"
4.1
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.1
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Fort Drum (near Village of Carthage), 10730 Enduring Freedom Dr, 13602, Fort Drum, US, United States
"I give him only four stars because the crust has no taste, at least for me. overall, the pizza is really good, and it is as good as it in NY-style piz..."
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Watertown (near Village of Carthage), 26216 Outer Pearl Street Route 283, Watertown, United States Of America, 13601
"Fantastic food. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Copenhagen (near Village of Carthage), 9794 State Route 12, Copenhagen, United States
"Great food and every time we go there, our server is super sweet!"