Bake Shop Bakes - Tyrone

Bakeries, Delivery Services
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Bake Shop Bakes

Bake Shop Bakes
4.9 / 5 (158 reviews)

Description

This cozy bakery-café shines with outstanding baked goods and sandwiches—think perfect BLTs on house-grilled bread, a standout Granny Italian, amazing apple dumplings, cheesecakes and brownies. Fast, generally friendly service and the ability to handle large groups make it a convenient stop, especially for I‑99 travelers. A few customers note unclear pricing on pastries, occasional service lapses, and the rare soggy or under-filled sandwich, but the tempting desserts and consistent quality keep patrons returning.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Gary

Feedback

★ 4.9 / 5 from 158 reviews
gary-89
23.07.2023

Best BLT my wife has ever had! I had the Granny Italian, which isn't simply a sized down sub, but a grilled sandwich that stands on its own excellent. Then there are the fresh baked goods...

jen-217
23.07.2023

Absolutely delicious! There are so many irresistible desserts that it's tough to walk away without buying something, and even tougher to leave with an empty stomach. I had a BLT served on their homemade grilled bread, and it was perfection.

cindy-454
23.07.2023

Miss going here. Order from a friend thru a fundraiser. I always want to try the banana spilt cheese cakeBest cheesecake ever. I also go the pb brownies and apple dumpling. Sorry I couldn't get photos.

cassidy-18
23.07.2023

The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful! The food was excellent, and they offered a great variety of delicious options.

tamira-3
23.07.2023

I went here for breakfast on the recommendation of another, but they only offer breakfast sandwiches. They were well made and tasty enough, it 's just not really what I was looking for. I wanted to try the apple dumpling since my mom made them when I was a kid, and it was pretty good too. I echo those who said prices would be very helpful on the baked good. Most of us like to make decisions on the worth vs cost of our choices internally and it 's disconcerting to have to ask the price of everything you might be interested in. I removed one star for the service. I ordered unsweet tea and was pretty sure she 'd given me sweet tea. I asked her if she could taste test the tea out of the container since I 'd already used sweetener in mine. She said I don 't drink iced tea and just ignored my request. Given I was the only customer at the time she should have addressed my concern and corrected the tea.

FAQ

You can use the WiFi of the place at no extra cost.

The restaurant also takes various credit cards.

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR code for the menu of Bake Shop Bakes

Suggested nearby restaurants.