Rotolo's Pizzeria - Tyler

I really enjoy stopping by for delicious food, great conversation, and a fantastic selection of beer!

The service was awful, and the pizza is no longer what it used to be! This used to be my favorite spot for pizza, but they must have changed the recipe. The pizza tasted like cardboard topped with sauce, cheese, and pepperoni. I was really disappointed! Rest in peace, my pizza dreams! I won’t be returning!

One of the best places my family and I have ever had pizza! The customer service was excellent, even with Benj (who was in training) and Ellie as our waiter and waitress. They were both very polite and welcoming. It was our family's first visit, and thanks to our wonderful experience there, God willing, we will definitely return. Thank you, team, for making our visit so memorable!

If you’re looking for pizza that doesn’t make you feel like you just drank a gallon of oil, then this is the place for you!Wow, the pizza I ordered had excellent flavor and texture. The crust was nice and thin, and not oily, the sauce was slightly sweet but very tasty, and the toppings were fresh!I got two pizzas and also got spaghetti that I added Tre Meatballs on top.The spaghetti was pretty good, but the meatballs were incredible! I could eat those all day long, lol. I should have also gotten a pizza with only sauce, cheese, and meatballs! That would have been perfect!One of the pizzas I ordered was Chicken Alfredo, because tomato sauce typically gives me indigestion, but after eating the other pizza I got I had nothing to worry about. No indigestion after eating this pizza!The second pizza was half for my wife (Canadian Bacon and cheese) and half for me (Bacon Cheeseburger). She loved her half and I loved mine! My brother enjoyed some of the Chicken Alfredo, and thought it was pretty good.This visit to Tyler TX was made better by having a pizza restaurant option like this!The ordering process online was super simple and gave me all the options I wanted.The service was fast, it was ready when I arrived (just had a little bit of a line to get through before I could let them know I was ready to pick up the food). The place looked great on the inside, and the staff were friendly and helpful!

Sad to say this place has gone from a 4 star to 1! I am really pissed, my family and I went in and took about 5 minutes for someone to come to the counter to seat us. OK that's fine that I can understand. The lady was nice enough to clean a booth off so my son can sit on his knees. But that's about as far as it went we got seated and NO ONE came to take our drink order for over 10 minutes. I am unsure of how long because I dtook my 3 yr old to the restroom. I did start a timer after we got back. I saw 5 servers walk by and no one came by. 2 other groups got seated after us and got their drinks and even took their food orders. So we left and will never go back! Parking: Unfortunately, being in a strip mall parking is a hit and miss. I had to circle around to find a spot. Noticed when I came out about 2 groups got out of their cars to go to a shop down the street. Kid-friendliness: I like how they have a connect four at the door. But other than that, I didn't notice how kidd friendly it was.