Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.4 out of 5
Impressive | 540 reviews

What User likes about Prairie Fire Pie:
We were pleasantly surprised by the amazing evening we had here! Our server was not just on top of everything from drink refills to taking our order to checking in, she was also so friendly and knew all about the menu. We enjoyed the happy hour half price pizzas and talked about the value the rest of the night. Overall such a positive experience and would highly recommend to anyone looking for a fun night out with ou... View all feedback. What User doesn't like about Prairie Fire Pie:
Made a reservation for 7:30pm on a Saturday night. When we arrived, they said they only had one server and could not honor our reservation. This was our first experience there. I’m disappointed that they took the reservation if they had no capacity. If they had shut down their open table, than we could have secured a Saturday night dinner out elsewhere. Instead we were forced into settling for fast food due to no oth... View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Menu
5.0 ★ from 40 reviews

Excellent attention by Spencer. The garlic parmesan wings were superb. We’ll be back for sure.

We were pleasantly surprised by the amazing evening we had here! Our server was not just on top of everything from drink refills to taking our order to checking...

read more

Food was great! Service was amazing! We will definitely go back.

Arnulfo
30.11.2021 - 07:13

The food and service are impeccable. We enjoyed wings and fontina for appetizers along with cocktails is amazing The pizzas are delicious and the sourdough crus...

read more

Mother’s Day pizza with kids was luxurious with you all!!! Thank you!!!

Despite some mixed experiences with reservations, service, and food quality, PFP offers a cozy atmosphere and a standout server. The pizza was hit or miss with some finding it too salty while others enjoyed unique toppings. Vegan and vegetarian options are available, making it a good spot for those with dietary restrictions. The kombucha and cauliflower appetizer were standouts for many, and patrons enjoyed the attentive service from Spencer. Overall, PFP offers a fun night out with good service and interesting pizza choices, with some room for improvement in customer service and consistency in food quality.

Restaurantji
4.6 ★ from 15 reviews
Emily
15.09.2024 - 21:30

The restaurant atmosphere was nice and the service was good. We found that the pizza itself was extremely salty, likely the dough, so it’s not something we’ll b...

read more
Kenny
15.09.2024 - 21:30

Amazing pizza and drinks. Would highly recommend this place for groups looking for a fun night

Daya
15.09.2024 - 21:30

I love this place! This is definitely a hidden gem! Spencer takes care of me everytime! He is very talkative and always encouraging me to try new things. Ever s...

read more
Hope
15.09.2024 - 21:30

Wonderful hostess and wait staff! Loved Spencer behind the bar. He makes the yummiest drinks! Try the cauliflower and Kale salad if your wanting to eat lighter....

read more
Tom
15.09.2024 - 21:30

We went to an early dinner on a Sunday afternoon. Food and drink options were all pretty fantastic. We had three flavors of chicken wings, of which our favorite...

read more
Opentable
4.7 ★ from 50 reviews

Just average. Flavor profile not spectacular and pizza was dry and average. Neat concept, but underwhelming. Cauliflower appetizer was good.

Who I think was the owner was very attentive. It’s obvious he is trying very hard to make this place a success. It’s got fun drinks and he even let us have the...

read more

Food is amazing!! First gluten free crust I’ve had that actually didn’t taste like cardboard, and Vegan options are plentiful. We found our new pizza spot

ChakaKahn
12.10.2023 - 10:47

Excellent service from Spencer. Thank you for always taking such good care of us.

ChakaKahn
12.10.2023 - 10:47

Burnt crostini and almost burnt pizzas. Please either calibrate the oven or retrain personnel in the kitchen.

Int Restaurants
4.3 ★ from 340 reviews
Amy
31.07.2023 - 13:33

Great food! Great atmosphere! I highly recommend checking this place out!! Chef Yancey's cooking is always on point!:

Tom
31.07.2023 - 13:33

I love all pizza! It would be hard to get a bad review from me. (That's not a challenge, by the way. Isa had the wings and I ordered a gluten-free pizza with sw...

read more
Sunshine
31.07.2023 - 13:33

Deliciousness, pure deliciousness ! ! ! Love the wings and cauliflower appetizer the pizzas are super tasty, the crust makes the pie !

Ian
31.07.2023 - 13:33

Got the potato pizza and it was amazing! Crust was perfecting the egg added just the right amount of flavor. Definitely coming back!

Susan
31.07.2023 - 13:33

Great atmosphere, perfect crust, flavorful Pizza. Love the bar choices including some non- alcoholic drinks.

Sirved
4.5 ★ from 95 reviews
Trace
25.11.2023 - 11:45

My favorite place to stop and have pizza while in town. Spencer is always so accommodating and friendly, has a fantastic array of drinks on the top of his mind...

read more
Trace
25.11.2023 - 11:45

Vegans, don't overlook Prairie Fire! They offer a homemade cashew cheese (which wasn't listed on the online menu when I ordered, so I had to call to request it)...

read more

Fantastic! The service, drinks, and food were all excellent. Our bartender/waiter, Spencer, was amazing. This was some of the best service we have ever had at a...

read more
Trace
25.11.2023 - 11:45

The pizza at this restaurant is excellent. The happy hour specials are also good. However, the garlic knot appetizer is a bit expensive for what you get - $7 fo...

read more
Trace
25.11.2023 - 11:45

I doordashed. Cost of pizza is $20.40. I'll let the pictures speak for themselves.

Good Rated Restaurants near Tulsa

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Tulsa, 3530 South Sheridan Road, Tulsa, 74145, United States Of America
"Amazing food (peanut curry). Super nice people."
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Tulsa, 1124 S Lewis Ave, 74104, Tulsa, US, United States
"Excellent food and fellowship"
4.7
Menu
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Open Now
City: Owasso (near Tulsa), 12308 East 86th St N, 74055, Owasso, US, United States
"I've sampled many pho places throughout Tulsa and Broken Arrow and have several goto's in both cities, as well as places to avoid. I learned about Kim..."
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Owasso (near Tulsa), 9045 N 121st East Ave, Owasso, United States
"As always, the food is fresh and delicious. Top notch."
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Owasso (near Tulsa), 9100 N Garnett Rd, 74055-4435, Owasso, United States
"BEST. PERIOD! Love their fries... Love their Jalapeño Chicken.. Always HOT upon arrival! The Chili... OOO, YES!"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Broken Arrow (near Tulsa), 3708 S Elm Place, Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, USA, 74011, United States
"Incredible sushi with very friendly staff!"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Owasso (near Tulsa), 13720 East 86th St N #200, Owasso, OK 74055, United States
"Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Tulsa, 114 S Detroit Ave, 74120, Tulsa, United States
"Always great Pizza with lots of different toppings that is very similar what I had in Italy. Great wine list and a very extensive beer list. Always wo..."
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Tulsa, 319 East Archer St, Tulsa, United States Of America
"Went for my mom's birthday! It was delicious! Highly recommend."
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Tulsa, 207 E Archer St, 74103, Tulsa, United States
"Great concept , great staff, food was way above what we expected."