NYC Pizza - Tulsa

#2 - Pizza - Tulsa, Cheese, Tea
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

NYC Pizza

NYC Pizza
4.0 / 5 (3304 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive menu of NYC Pizza from Tulsa featuring all 28 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu.

NYC Pizza in Tulsa has received mixed reviews from customers. While some have praised the establishment for serving some of the best and cheapest pizza in town, others have criticized the rude and unwelcoming service they experienced. Despite the lack of friendliness from the staff, many patrons appreciate the authentic New York-style pizza that NYC Pizza offers. The hand-tossed crust, piping hot slices, and sweet sauce have garnered positive feedback. Overall, NYC Pizza seems to be a popular destination for those seeking a taste of NYC in Tulsa, even if the service may not always meet expectations.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: DanR2405

Images

NYC Pizza Food NYC Pizza Food NYC Pizza Food NYC Pizza Food NYC Pizza Food NYC Pizza Food NYC Pizza Food NYC Pizza Food

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 3304 reviews

Was Julie McInnes Trickler at NYC Pizza a mag?
Seriously awesome pizza! Thon crust without the feeling of eating a cracker with pizza toppings. Huge slices and pies, great prices. We'll never order from any of the big c;hain restaurant's again! View all feedback.

What Alejandra White dislikes about NYC Pizza:
Rudest service I have ever experienced! After calling in a pizza, it still wasn't ready over an hour later. When I told the owner I didn't have time to wait for it, he screamed at me to take my business elsewhere and get out of his restaurant. I am still in shock that anyone would treat a regular customer this way. I certainly won't be returning. View all feedback.

steuber-albina
31.08.2017

Some of the best, cheapest pizza I've ever had anywhere. Went here and got a plain cheese by the slice for only $2.20. The slices are huge. They warm them up for you in the oven so they are piping hot and the cheese is perfectly good and melted. The hand tossed crust was amazing. Crunchy yet thin and flexible so you can fold it in half to eat. My favorite thing about the pizza is the sauce, which is perfectly sweet. I'll be back soon for lunch.

hayes-audra
31.08.2017

Loud and Obnoxious. Just like home use to be in NY. They serve up one of the better pies in the area and their loud talking and such just gives it that authentic charm.

vlakin-1
12.12.2017

Love the pizza hereIt reminded us of our trip to New York City a few years back.

danr2405
30.05.2024

Crust was so tough, I could not bite through it, had to tear sections off. The rest of the food there, is just there. I have eaten there three times, and will not go back.

johnforcop
30.05.2024

The pizza, available by the slice or as a whole, is a great selection, reminiscent of homemade pizza. It's conveniently located near the Trade Winds Hotel, making it easily accessible on foot.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.