Tomahawk Pizza

#2 - Pizza - Tomahawk, Sandwiches, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Tomahawk Pizza

Tomahawk Pizza
4.3 / 5 (39 reviews)

Description

The Windmill is a longtime northern Wisconsin favorite serving wildly generous scoops of rotating, flavorful ice cream with friendly, efficient service. Summer evenings bring lines that move quickly; a small seating area and nearby lake and bridge make it a perfect stop for families, boaters and cabin visitors. Prices are reasonable for the portions, though tiny/child sizes have been removed and it’s cash-only. There’s usually at least one non-dairy option daily.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Randy

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 39 reviews
julia-s-cactus6
20.07.2024

I absolutely love the Windmill! I can't imagine anyone not enjoying it! The flavors are fantastic, and the service is excellent. The atmosphere is incredibly cozy, and there's a lovely lake nearby.

katherine-m-doctor9
20.07.2024

I've been visiting this place for over 20 years, and the service is always excellent. You get an abundance of ice cream at a wonderful price. This restaurant is truly a hidden gem in northern Wisconsin!

anna-r-library220
20.07.2024

How can you not LOVE The Windmill! I've been stopping by every time I visit our cabin for as long as I can remember—at least when they’re open. The selection of ice cream is incredible, and the staff is always friendly! The prices are reasonable, and there are various options for cones and dishes. Just a heads up—the scoops are usually larger than you anticipate! With so many flavors on offer, constantly changing, you’re bound to find something you’ll love. Expect a line out the door on summer evenings, but trust me, the wait is well worth it! They’ve recently made some changes to improve the flow inside. You can grab your ice cream, pay, and then head out to a little seating area, or walk back to your boat or down the trail to enjoy it. Just remember, it's cash only; they don't accept cards.

randy-webie-fish7680
09.10.2024

They offer the best pizza I've ever tasted from a small-town restaurant!

peyton-schweitzer-1
09.10.2024

I wouldn't even give this place a single star if I didn't have to rate it to leave a review. This was my first time ordering two pizzas from this gas station. We followed the cooking instructions carefully, but now we're both feeling unwell after eating the pizzas just last night. I don't think we'll be getting their pizza again, and I would really appreciate a refund for the order.

FAQ

The restaurant offers complimentary WLAN for its guests.

The restaurant also takes credit cards from the common providers for payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.