Pine Tree Supper Club - Feedback

Hostess was rude and a bully. Her name was Lee. Our waitress Melissa was confused, harried, and overwhelmed with 16 patrons and other tables. Our salad we're pr... read more Hostess was rude and a bully. Her name was Lee. Our waitress Melissa was confused, harried, and overwhelmed with 16 patrons and other tables. Our salad we're pre made and look sad only choice of dressing was ranch and french. We were not provided rolls or allowed to use salad bar. We could only order a limited menu. Got drinks after salad and no rolls. One of us wanted a loaded bake potato and was told to go to the salad bar. The hostess scolded them for using salad bar. Sadly, our meals were all delicious. Even though we got no choice in how to cook our ribeye steaks. They were all medium rate. We received no drink refills. Our bills took 30 minutes to calculate. Melissa was pleasant throughout. Parking: Very limited. We have been visiting this restaurant once a year for 20 yrs but will not be coming back Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 3 Recommended dishes: Ribeye and Stuffed Shrimp Parking space: Difficult to find parking Parking options: Free street parking

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 read more Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

Very comfortable atmosphere. Service well above average. Bartender was spot on. Our waitress friendly and very accommodating. Will make a second visit in the fu... read more Very comfortable atmosphere. Service well above average. Bartender was spot on. Our waitress friendly and very accommodating. Will make a second visit in the future Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Ribeye and Stuffed Shrimp

Staff was very friendly and knowledgeable. Got us seated right away even without a reservation and it was a busy Saturday night. Salad bar had a wide variety of... read more Staff was very friendly and knowledgeable. Got us seated right away even without a reservation and it was a busy Saturday night. Salad bar had a wide variety of offerings, including some unexpected specialties (i.e. hot meatballs). Our reasonably priced Entrees arrived quickly, Prime Rib for my husband and Stuffed Shrimp for myself.....EXCELLENT for both! Also highly recommend the garlic, parmesan butter mashed potatoes for your side....definitely not low on calorie but amazing flavor so well worth the treat! Highly recommend this establishment if you are in the area!!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 read more Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

This place has excellent food, the service is fast, and the staff is extremely accommodating. They've accommodated our last minute parties of eight on a busy Sa... read more This place has excellent food, the service is fast, and the staff is extremely accommodating. They've accommodated our last minute parties of eight on a busy Saturday night a couple of times now. As a former server host, I know that's an awfully big ask. Not only did they make it happen, they were gracious. Also, this place has the best mushroom swiss burger my husband has ever had--seriously, he talks about it like it is a long-lost love. I'm pretty sure he loves this burger more than he loves me, but after tasting it... I get it.

Every time I am here, I sigh a big sigh of relief of being in Wisconsin again. It feels like the whole state is giving me a big hug every time I walk in the doo... read more Every time I am here, I sigh a big sigh of relief of being in Wisconsin again. It feels like the whole state is giving me a big hug every time I walk in the door. We liked the Brandy Old Fashioned so much, we got some of their mix to bring home.

The steaks were amazing as we're the drinks. A solid supper club experience. I think the lighting in the back room was a little dim and the rock and roll radio... read more The steaks were amazing as we're the drinks. A solid supper club experience. I think the lighting in the back room was a little dim and the rock and roll radio station wasn't great but the waitresses really made the experience solid. The prices were extremely reasonable. I'd go back.

I asked for a reservation. They let us know that they had no reservations this night and wait very shorthanded. We went in anyway. We're here at 5:30 and have a... read more I asked for a reservation. They let us know that they had no reservations this night and wait very shorthanded. We went in anyway. We're here at 5:30 and have a table right away. The Hostess let us know that they were very shorthanded and that they work 3 servers and eat 3 large groups. We waited a bit. But the hostess came and checked for us and found that we were not greeted by a server. She got an order pad and was our server for the evening. One of the bartenders also helped with waiting tables. We were here about 90 minutes. I've waited longer than some places just for a table on a Saturday for Prime Rib. The food was fantastic and came out quite quickly after our order. Even short Handed was the staff in good moods and ran quite well to let things go! Even with some rude/imbulant customers who could not capture the situation and that they did the best they could. Kudos to all work for a job well done under pressure and keep things going!

I've visited this restaurant several times, and the food has been outstanding on each occasion. They offer a delightful salad bar, and the Saturday Prime Rib is... read more I've visited this restaurant several times, and the food has been outstanding on each occasion. They offer a delightful salad bar, and the Saturday Prime Rib is both juicy and tender. The Friday fish fry is wonderfully flavored with garlic and comes in a generous portion. I sampled my aunt's fried shrimp, which are quite large! The fried pork chops appeared to be thick cuts from a pork loin and were very delicious. It's a great little gem in North Forest, and my entire family enjoyed their experience here.

The restaurant serves delicious food and amazing drinks. The steaks are always fresh and delicious, and the pizzas are also great. The salads are fantastic too. read more The restaurant serves delicious food and amazing drinks. The steaks are always fresh and delicious, and the pizzas are also great. The salads are fantastic too.

The food is delicious and thoughtfully prepared. The service was a bit slow, but we weren’t in a rush. The decor has a charming 'northwoods' vibe, which is just... read more The food is delicious and thoughtfully prepared. The service was a bit slow, but we weren’t in a rush. The decor has a charming 'northwoods' vibe, which is just right! The staff seemed overwhelmed by our large group, especially since many did not make reservations ahead of time, so we contributed to the situation.

The Pine Tree Supper Club showcases all the classic elements of a traditional supper club, including cozy low lighting, an ample self-serve salad bar, and tende... read more The Pine Tree Supper Club showcases all the classic elements of a traditional supper club, including cozy low lighting, an ample self-serve salad bar, and tender, delicious steaks. This restaurant truly excels at...

We had a fantastic time dining at a traditional Wisconsin supper club for a fish fry. It was the highlight of our family reunion in Northern Wisconsin, as my da... read more We had a fantastic time dining at a traditional Wisconsin supper club for a fish fry. It was the highlight of our family reunion in Northern Wisconsin, as my dad couldn't stop raving about it. The lake perch fish fry was particularly delicious.

The food here is the finest in the Northwoods! The prime rib is outstanding, and the seafood chowder is simply exceptional. read more The food here is the finest in the Northwoods! The prime rib is outstanding, and the seafood chowder is simply exceptional.

The only challenge is deciding what to order because everything is so delicious! read more The only challenge is deciding what to order because everything is so delicious!