Reviews
What Ashley likes about Old Mill Ice Cream Shop:
Delicious! We just moved here and have been coming almost every week. Prices are great. The serving size are huge. Friendly! I am sad they are close for the season. View all feedback.
What Clifford F doesn't like about Old Mill Ice Cream Shop:
Trendy ice cream where you play quite a bit for some ice cream from Farr's. It's fun, it's a cute atmosphere, but it's also the same price for a half gallon at a grocery store as it is for a double scoop waffle cone. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Delicious ice cream! It is a bit pricey (we spent around $16 for just the three of us, in case that gives you an idea), but the portions are generous, and they...
read moreDelicious ice cream in a charming, authentic small-town setting. The scenic drive from Alpine is definitely worth it. Be sure to try the wild huckleberry flavor...
read moreThe ice cream was good. I love the huckleberry. Staff was friendly and service quick.
I had amazing milkshakes here, and it's definitely a place I'll return to.
Trendy ice cream where you play quite a bit for some ice cream from Farr's. It's fun, it's a cute atmosphere, but it's also the same price for a half gallon at...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe staff is incredibly friendly and always has a smile on their faces!
Loved the raspberry cheesecake ice cream!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more