Reviews
What Tamara P doesn't like about Bagelicious Cafe:
The pictures say it all. We ordered delivery. Two of these same bagels were ordered. Barely any cream cheese and only on 1 side. This was an everything w/cream cheese, bacon jalapeños $10-11 each. It's advertised as 6 slices of bacon on the menu. There were maybe 3 slices, cut into halves. Trying to support local becomes challenging when this is what's they're sending out. Hopefully, they will work on quality and exe... View all feedback. What rainlynn oddo likes about Bagelicious Cafe:
My experience was amazing but my BEC was incredible I mean look at it. This is the ockiest bagel I’ve had on Long Island in a long time. And the service was great they called me by name which I love. Def coming here again for a BEC the Ocky way View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The pictures say it all. We ordered delivery. Two of these same bagels were ordered. Barely any cream cheese and only on 1 side. This was an everything w/cream...
read moreBest bagel store around, clean and great food and service
To meet one of the best vehicles in the whole island recommend this place cleanliness freshness. The staff are very helpful.
I am a city person who moved here 30years ago...Bagelicious comes close to my favorite place in the city. LOVE these BAGELS. THE BEST in the area.
My go to bagel store while in Port Jefferson area. Solid fresh bagels and good ice coffee. You cannot go wrong. Strawberry cream cheese... it is amazing!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more