Casey's - Taylorville

#23 - Fast Food - Taylorville, #35 - Pizza - Taylorville, Breakfast
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Casey's

Casey's
3.4 / 5 (183 reviews)

Description

A bustling Taylorville convenience hub known for superior pizza, fresh donuts and full-service fuel, this Casey’s excels at quick meals and stocked snacks. Cooks and many staff are praised, but reliability falters: iced coffee and some pumps are often unavailable, rewards access and cash-back policies feel restrictive, and occasional overcharging or inattentive service frustrate loyal customers. Ideal for convenience seekers and drivers who want fast food and fuel, but expect inconsistent service.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Hartman

Feedback

★ 3.4 / 5 from 183 reviews
disturbist
08.09.2024

Cashiers are all rude, doesn't seem to matter what shift. But the worst is the SMELL. For over the past month every time I try to go into this Casey's it reeks so badly of dirty more like rotten mop water. To the point that my eyes water. I really tried to give them the benefit of the doubt, but I don't know if they don't care by this point or what. I wouldn't eat here based off the smell alone.

lacsey-sparling-2
08.09.2024

Great service convenient and now open all night again last I knew ....cindy nation is the manager and has always ran the one on spresser very well

gerald-mathias-1
08.09.2024

I just moved to Taylorville little over year ago. This Casey is the worst Casey's I have experienced when it comes to getting fuel. Either pumps have bags over handles out of order. Or you go threw all the steps to start fueling with paying at pump and it does nothing. Do better Casey's. So I will be getting my gas elsewhere. Besides that it's OK store.

hartman-gina-1
08.09.2024

If you want convenience this is the place. You’ll pay the price for that service too. The best place for pizza, gas, beer and cigarettes and everything possible to snack on!

andrew-douglas-fern0
08.09.2024

Only allows you to get cash back on debit transactions once, and give you a bunch of flack if you try to split transactions to get back to back cash back. At least Circle K down the street lets you get $30 back at a time. Will only go there in the future.

FAQ

The restaurant also accepts credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.