The Reluctant Navigator - Tall Timbers

This place is still open, but it is seasonal. I believe they are open some holidays year-round and weekends from memorial day to labor day. Yelp needs to update that. The staff are great and the food is delicious. Their own fresh oysters are a highlight. A plus is that it is a beautiful spot.

It is no longer open. I had to give stars to write this. Never eaten here as it was closed when we showed up. 2/25/2023

I've been here three times so far (once for dinner, twice for Sunday breakfast buffet). I've never had a bad experience. Service was great and staff is really friendly and makes you feel like a regular even on your first visit. For dinner, my wife had fish and chips (catfish for the fish which was different in a good way) and I had the snakehead (which to me tasted similar to catfish with a better texture). Definitely looking forward to trying other dishes. My wife loves the sweet bacon and grits in the breakfast buffet. Server recommended I try the bread pudding, which I am normally not a fan of, but there's was delicious. Anyone looking for some good seafood in a casual and friendly atmosphere should check this place out.

We have gone here many times for their Sunday Brunch. The food is always really good and the servers are really good (if not overwhelmed at times). The only complaint is that sometimes the person making omelettes gets so busy that we end up leaving before the Omelettes are ready (SADLY). I have to recommend this place for brunch and be sure to order the Bloody Mary (they are really good).

I can't believe we waited so long to go here. We tried it on a Saturday night recently and it was excellent! Owner was there and greeted us on arrival. He had a table with a great view quickly bussed for us. Service was quick. We had the rockfish nite appetizer, oyster po' boy with fries, seafood platter, and one member of our party had a burger. All were really good. Rockfish bites were large and perfectly cooked with a sweet chili sauce. Platters were huge with soft shell, shrimp, oysters, crab balls, and two sides. Crab balls were meaty, crab was well seasoned, oysters were large and plentiful. The platter would have fed two of us. Po' boy was great with many oysters and a lightly toasted fresh roll. It was just a great experience. Highly recommended. Oh! We had the key lime cheesecake, even though we weren't hungry at all. Also excellent with lime rinds, a good crust, and great texture. I added a few pictures.