Luigi's Pizza Italian - Syracuse

#1 - Pizza - Syracuse, Italian, Vegetarian Friendly
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Luigi's Pizza Italian

Luigi's Pizza Italian
3.9 / 5 (2540 reviews)

Description

Patrons of this Italian eatery share a varied dining experience, oscillating between disappointment and delight. While some customers lament undercooked dishes, lackluster flavors, and uninviting cold breads, others rave about generous servings and standout specialties like prime rib and unique pizzas loaded with garlic. Compliments pour in for the delightful cavatelli and the restaurant’s warm, family-friendly atmosphere. However, leadership changes and inconsistent food quality leave some diners questioning their loyalty. Regulars cherish nostalgic moments, but new visitors might find a mixed bag of culinary outcomes, suggesting that reliability in quality has become a significant concern.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Christopher

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 2540 reviews
christopher-gilkes
26.08.2024

I was really impressed by how nice and respectful the waiter was. The food was fantastic, especially their lemonade—it’s truly delicious! I definitely plan to return. As for kid-friendliness, they treat everyone with respect, and I know the manager personally; they often share valuable life lessons with us.

john-youz-guyzleach
26.08.2024

Absolutely AMAZING! One of the best places around! The people are friendly and genuinely nice. The food is spectacular, bursting with delicious Italian flavors! My all-time favorite is the baked ziti with meatballs the size of baseballs. Plus, the staff has a great sense of humor!

le-potato
26.08.2024

I'll be honest: it's not great. I really don't understand how it has so many positive reviews. I don't want to offend anyone's taste, but seriously—the sauce is off, almost sour. The pizza crust lacks flavor, and the toppings are soggy. Overall, it's just not enjoyable.

marcum-waguespack
26.08.2024

I was craving for some italian foods, and luigi's always been the best! I also had the fried haddock supper with excellent crusty Italian bread, a side salad, and fresh cut fries. It was open conveniently for lunch. Everything they proudly serve is fresh.Excellent customer service and polite employees. Try it Luigi now!

kelly-kinard-weed999
26.08.2024

We've been coming here since I was a child and it always brings back memories. In fact my uncle who recently passed away used to work here when he was young. The food is always delicious and the server went above and beyond during our most recent visit. Everything was wonderful and definitely makes the 1.5 hours of driving worth every minute!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.