Bagel Master - Syosset

Salads, Bagels, Breakfast
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Bagel Master

Bagel Master
3.8 / 5 (6238 reviews)

Menu

The restaurant from Syosset offers 26 different courses and drinks on the menu for an average price of $7.9.

Bagel Master in Syosset, NY offers delicious American cuisine with a stellar 4.3 star average rating. Open from 6:00 AM to 4:00 PM, call ahead at (516) 921-9773 to reserve a table or place an order for delivery through DoorDash. Enjoy the convenience of NFC mobile payments. If you're looking to explore new dining options, consider trying Platía Greek Kitchen or El Parral Restaurant. Leave a review if you've dined here before!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Carol

Images

Bagel Master Food Bagel Master Food Bagel Master Food Bagel Master Logo Bagel Master Drink Bagel Master Food Bagel Master Menu Bagel Master Food

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 6238 reviews

This beloved bagel shop, once a local favorite, is facing a wave of mixed reviews. While many patrons cherish its warm atmosphere and friendly staff, recent frustrations have surfaced regarding order accuracy and rising prices. Though certain menu items, like the He-Man breakfast wrap and Acme’s Finest, receive praise for their quality, inconsistent execution has led some to seek alternatives. The limited parking and tight seating further complicate the dining experience. Despite its challenges, loyal customers still appreciate the fresh bagels and inviting ambiance, hoping for a return to the consistency that made it a neighborhood staple.

bulelwa28
17.06.2023

I can't live without the whole wheat flagels!!!!! I have tried bagels everywhere and by far...these are the best!!!

oliver02
17.06.2023

Best Bagels, salads, lox and people! Always great service too!!!

thamill-2
17.06.2023

Bagel Master is by far the best I ever had. Great service, good food and management sets the customer first. I recommend a special sandwich. They won't be disappointed.

carol-joy-ortiz-tree
30.12.2023

I used to visit this restaurant regularly, but lately, I've been let down. The prices have increased, the wait times have lengthened, and my orders are frequently not prepared as I requested. I've come to prefer East Norwich bagels, as they have outshined this restaurant in my view. The prices here have become unreasonable and the service has declined. East Norwich bagels are definitely my top choice now.

carol-joy-ortiz-1
30.12.2023

**Service:** The staff was friendly and very attentive. **Food/Drink:** I tried Acme's Finest, featuring three perfectly cooked over-medium eggs, cream cheese, tomato, cucumber, and sliced nova on a whole wheat everything bagel. It was delicious, though a bit messy, but the bagel had the perfect size and texture. The meal also came with complimentary hot chocolate, which was quite good. I also enjoyed the egg salad on a whole wheat everything bagel; it was tasty as well. Additionally, I had Mike's Philly Fluff Pound Cake, and it was absolutely delicious.

  • Dinner Options

    Baked Everything Chicken Dinner
    Baked Everything Chicken Dinner

    1 lb. Baked chicken + everything bagel seasoning.

    $11.7
    Chicken Cutlets Dinner
    Chicken Cutlets Dinner

    1 lb.

    $10.7
  • Sliced Cheese

    Alpine Lace Swiss Sliced Cheese
    Alpine Lace Swiss Sliced Cheese
    $4.9
    Finlandia Imported Swiss Sliced Cheese
    Finlandia Imported Swiss Sliced Cheese
    $4.9
  • Signature Choices

    Potato Pancake Breakfast
    Potato Pancake Breakfast
    $1.7
  • Fish

    Belly Lox
    Belly Lox
    $11.5

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.