Tony Maronni's - Sussex

The crust and the genuine Italian sauce make Tony's pizza our favorite. We look forward to enjoying our beloved Tony's pizza every Friday night! We've also treated our host family to Tony's several times, and they love it just as much as we do!

This is the best pizza in town! I tried the thin and crispy Margherita, and it was fantastic. The combination of sweet, fresh basil and robust garlic, along with the garden-fresh Roma tomatoes, made it a truly delightful experience.

Tony Maroni offers a tasty pizza, but the Greek salad could use some work. Instead of pineapple, it should include mozzarella bites, black and Greek olives, Roma tomatoes, and a proper Greek vinaigrette. I also wish they would serve more of their stuffed mushrooms rather than larger ones.

Authentic!. I liked it, it reminded me of my trip to Italy. Restaurants in Italy are all ad hoc with unsurpassed plates, some cheesy decoration, but serous passion for food. The cook had serious passion for his food, you can say he loved Italian food only by his hat (if you were there, you know what I am talking about). He makes all his food out of the ground, and the pizza was to die! This is my new favorite place to get pizza!

Don't judge this book by its cover. Although this place might look a little sketchy from the outside and inside, I can assure you, this place is for real!! The food was fantastic. The owner/chef told me everything is homemade and believe me...you can really taste the quality and passion that is put into the food. We ordered 3 different pizzas and all were very good. The crust and sauce were outstanding!! The one test I like to do to see if a restaurant is quality or not...is the coffee test, order a cup of coffee. If the coffee is fresh, good, and smooth, you know the chef pays attention to details in his kitchen. This coffee was very good, smooth, not bitter, and fresh. Best pizza place in Waukesha County!