Yucatan - Sumter

#12 - Mexican - Sumter, Casual, Full
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Yucatan

Yucatan
3.8 / 5 (1130 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Yucatan in Sumter. Right now there are 70 meals and drinks in the menu.

Yucatan has sparked a whirlwind of opinions among diners. While some patrons rave about the prompt service and vibrant atmosphere, others find the food lacking authenticity and flavor. Complaints about bland dishes, small portions, and unclean facilities contrast sharply with those who claim it as the best Mexican eatery in Sumter. Some highlight attentive service, whereas others experienced inattentiveness during their visits. Ultimately, this restaurant seems to be a polarizing establishment, catering to a diverse range of palates, leaving many diners questioning its culinary reputation. Expect varied experiences if you decide to visit.

Last update: 23.01.2026 from: David

Images

Yucatan Food Yucatan Food Yucatan Food Yucatan Food Yucatan Food Yucatan Inside Yucatan Outside Yucatan Food

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 1130 reviews

Was Anonym at Yucatan a mag?
This establishment was fantastic! We were seated quickly and the service was prompt. I have traveled extensively and dined in many places, some of which were quite awful, but this place was a pleasant surprise. View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about Yucatan:
The food is consistently overcooked, improperly seasoned, or undercooked. Both I and my companion have dined at this restaurant twice, and each time we ended up with food poisoning. It is not worth the expense. View all feedback.

curtis-colburn
11.11.2023

The burritos were smaller than expected, with only small pieces of chicken and melted cheese inside. The chicken seemed processed and possibly canned. We paid 10.50 for two small burritos. Additionally, the ceiling panels and lights were dirty.

jeannie-nelson
11.11.2023

The service was good and the TexMex atmosphere was okay, but the food was terrible and disgusting. Despite being popular in Sumter, this restaurant doesn't know how to make decent TexMex food. I can only give this place 1 star because, even with good service, the food is inedible.

shellbelladingdong
11.11.2023

YUCATAN..... NOT IMPRESSED.... This restaurant is extremely disappointing. The food is subpar and lacks flavor. The only decent thing they serve is their chips. As a Hispanic person, I find it offensive that they claim to serve authentic cuisine when everything tastes like it came from a can and was microwaved. Despite all the hype, I found everything to be bland and haphazardly plated. Those who enjoy dining here must have unsophisticated palates, as this is far from authentic Mexican cuisine. I feel sorry for anyone who considers this place a culinary gem.

david-lowe-1
11.11.2023

Great service. Great food. Generous portions. Reasonably priced.

david-bowman-3
11.11.2023

This place is probably the best Mexican place in sumter, the food is always great the service is usually on par. I don't really have any complaints or concerns like I said the foods always delicious.

Menu

  • Appetizers

    Jalapeno Poppers Ala Carte
    Jalapeno Poppers Ala Carte
  • Kids Menu

    2. One Taco & One Burrito With Beans
    2. One Taco & One Burrito With Beans
    6. One Quesadilla With Added Cheese
    6. One Quesadilla With Added Cheese
    8. Chicken Fries With French Fries
    8. Chicken Fries With French Fries
    9. Chicken Tender With Guacamole Salad
    9. Chicken Tender With Guacamole Salad
    10. Taco With Fried
    10. Taco With Fried

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.