Reviews - Selah
Reviews summary
Located in the charming town of Struthers, Ohio, Selah restaurant offers a sophisticated atmosphere with a unique reuse of a once bustling bank building. With delicious made-from-scratch Italian cuisine, this hidden gem impresses with its romantic setting and attention to detail. From fresh bread and warm olive to mussels and the best gnocchi, Selah delivers an unforgettable dining experience. Patrons can enjoy live music during the summer months, making it a must-visit spot for those looking for great food and a stylish ambiance. Whether it's a casual lunch with friends or a romantic dinner, Selah promises a memorable dining experience that will leave you coming back for more.
Was James wilson at Selah a mag?
Very good for the area, great service, nice reuse of the building too, if you are in the area go try it you will like it a lot of the food and desserts are made at the restaurant and will take you even if you don't have reservations too. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Soup View all feedback.
What Marianne Glass dislikes about Selah:
Dropped by for lunch. We were seated outside on a cloudy, chili, breezy day with nothing but a bottle of water (no glasses) and silverware. We waited 15 minutes and left. WORST SERVICE EVER!!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1 View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 07.09.2024
Perfect dining experience
I finish everything half
When you spin the wheel of what to eat for dinner tonight? be sure to add Selah to that list! We came here for something new to try based off a referral from my cousin. First off, the atmosphere is quaint and warm yet vibrant at the same time. There is a great mix of old history and new decor. The service was exceptional and the staff all seemed to work very well together!Now onto the stuff that most people actually care about... the food.Appetizers were the meat and cheese plate and the whipped feta with honey. The meat and cheese plate was good, but let 's be honest, it 's a meat and cheese plate. BUT the whipped feta with honey was exceptional! Imagine a honey drizzled cheesecake, minus the whole cake setting.For dinner I got the Niagara Falls Walleye with asparagus and it was cooked perfectly. Sauteed in a brown butter sauce and very flaky yet not crumbly. My wife got the gnocchi and meatballs with ricotta. All of which are make in house! The meatballs are tender yet they don 't disintegrate in the sauce. The gnocchi definitely holds it 's own with a great texture!Dessert was their made in house banana salted caramel cake and the French vanilla cake. Both of which were good but the banana salted caramel stole the show by far.All in all we had a good experience and will be back! A solid 8.2!
Fabulous service! Fabulous food!Thank you for a wonderful birthday!. ?
Amazing handmade pasta, fantastic staff, and I adore the cozy 6-seat bar with the best craft cocktail bartenders. Don’t forget to try the assorted layer cakes made on-site!
Last update : 31.08.2024
Love this place food is great best sauce in town!!!
Had lunch there for the first time. Great waitress and delicious food
I came to hear music and got some good food as well. It was a busy night and service was slow, but since we were there for the show primarily, it worked out well for us! One of our servers wasn’t the most friendly, but the other gentlemen was great and made up for that. Great time overall!
Beautiful building with great history. The food was not great. Potato soup lacked potatoes and wraps were soso. I would not eat there again.
From the style to the atmosphere, the food, and it's presentation. There are few if any places around that can match selah, if at all. Combining a uniqueness that few see value in, i can hardly remember enjoying myself as much as i have here. My strong recommendation, is the salmon with citrus sauce.
Last update : 21.11.2023
I couldn't have enjoyed this place more. We had dinner before the show at their theater upstairs. The service was top notch and the food was beyond compare. I can't hardly wait to go again. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Stopped there for lunch. Had a bean and sausage soup. Delicious
Very good for the area, great service, nice reuse of the building too, if you are in the area go try it you will like it a lot of the food and desserts are made at the restaurant and will take you even if you don't have reservations too. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Soup
Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Great local place to dine, will definitely go back. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Salad with Their Home Made Dressing, Soup, Bread Plate Free with Dinner Available During Lunch if Requested, Pecan Chicken, Salads
Last update : 12.05.2023
Had shrimp Florentine Linguine. It was delicious and had lunch for my wife the next day.
I look forward to the Gnocchi all week. How does an Italian restaurant run on a Saturday evening from Gnocchi? Answer: We've been busy making our Easter bread. So to hell with our menu items we make more money to sell our bread? Yes I gave 4 stars. The food, drinks, dessert, atmosphere was very good.. But if you eat $100.00 for two people pasta and then they don't have the pasta you want? I see you reserved my table with name cards. If I order my food when I make my reservation, can you put my name on it until I get there? Maybe again....maybe....
I stole my wife for her 30 with two friends. The food was great! The fried mozzarella was great along with all our cocktails. My wife and her boyfriend couldn't say enough great things about her espresso martinis! Between the steaks, gnocchi combo and pecan krusted chicken, I think that everyone left that satisfied. Only complaints, and seems to be together, our server had disappeared for a long time.
Very cozy and interesting atmosphere. The homemade bread and desserts are great. The food was fresh and delicious. Service was great. The first time there today, but will be again!
Selah restaurant is a hidden gem! Selah has been open 15 years but still remains fresh and new feeling. This amazing restaurant features delicious made from scratch Italian cuisine in a romantic atmosphere. Selah's embraced the features from the historic bank formally at the location in a unique and stylish way! From the beautiful marble tellers counters to the private dining vault Selah's style is sure to impress. Have an expresso on the patio, a lunch with friends, or romantic dinner with your significant other Selah's is the place to go. We were told Selah's has live music throughout the summer too. We can not wait to come back and visit again. Our dinner started with fresh baked Italian bread, warm olive and roasted peppers, followed with mussels and the best gnocchi I have ever eaten, and finished with lattes.
