Selah - Feedback

Went for lunch and waited 45 minutes to get served. Fish wasn't cooked and my sandwich was terrible. Teresa was very slow and unprofessional. We were only ones... read more Went for lunch and waited 45 minutes to get served. Fish wasn't cooked and my sandwich was terrible. Teresa was very slow and unprofessional. We were only ones there and took so long. She was at bar area talking to people. Asked for check and she went to take people who just sat down orders! Never brought check so we went to bar where she was. Took an hour to get our food. She was rude told me I was impatient! Bad service and food. We will never go back and I'm telling everyone I know not to go there. Overpriced for what we got.

I reserved a table a day in advance. I get in, and get seated. It takes over 20 minutes for anyone to greet me or take my order! On top of that all the food has... read more I reserved a table a day in advance. I get in, and get seated. It takes over 20 minutes for anyone to greet me or take my order! On top of that all the food has gone up 4-5$ and nothing about it changed. They also never answer their phones so good luck calling management. Careless service, and overpriced food. This place is the definition of going downhill .

Great atmosphere. Delicious food. And a good variety items on the menu. Drinks can be better read more Great atmosphere. Delicious food. And a good variety items on the menu. Drinks can be better

The best dining experience my husband and I have had in years. Amazing homemade food and kind souls. read more The best dining experience my husband and I have had in years. Amazing homemade food and kind souls.

6 good friends had a Wonderful dinner in the Vault Room tonight!! Amazing hospitality, service, and Food!! Thank you read more 6 good friends had a Wonderful dinner in the Vault Room tonight!! Amazing hospitality, service, and Food!! Thank you

This hidden gem is nestled in the metro Youngstown areaI was visiting my boyfriend and stopped by here to check it out. read more This hidden gem is nestled in the metro Youngstown areaI was visiting my boyfriend and stopped by here to check it out.

Out of everywhere in the Youngstown area, this place has captivated both my eyes and my stomach, and maybe a little of my heart! With an elegant 1920's read more Out of everywhere in the Youngstown area, this place has captivated both my eyes and my stomach, and maybe a little of my heart! With an elegant 1920's

I wish I could give this place a higher review because I love the atmosphere there! Such a cool place, food was okayIt was good but nothing special. read more I wish I could give this place a higher review because I love the atmosphere there! Such a cool place, food was okayIt was good but nothing special.

Had shrimp Florentine Linguine. It was delicious and had lunch for my wife the next day. read more Had shrimp Florentine Linguine. It was delicious and had lunch for my wife the next day.

I look forward to the Gnocchi all week. How does an Italian restaurant run on a Saturday evening from Gnocchi? Answer: We've been busy making our Easter bread.... read more I look forward to the Gnocchi all week. How does an Italian restaurant run on a Saturday evening from Gnocchi? Answer: We've been busy making our Easter bread. So to hell with our menu items we make more money to sell our bread? Yes I gave 4 stars. The food, drinks, dessert, atmosphere was very good.. But if you eat $100.00 for two people pasta and then they don't have the pasta you want? I see you reserved my table with name cards. If I order my food when I make my reservation, can you put my name on it until I get there? Maybe again....maybe....

I couldn't have enjoyed this place more. We had dinner before the show at their theater upstairs. The service was top notch and the food was beyond compare. I c... read more I couldn't have enjoyed this place more. We had dinner before the show at their theater upstairs. The service was top notch and the food was beyond compare. I can't hardly wait to go again. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Stopped there for lunch. Had a bean and sausage soup. Delicious read more Stopped there for lunch. Had a bean and sausage soup. Delicious

Very good for the area, great service, nice reuse of the building too, if you are in the area go try it you will like it a lot of the food and desserts are made... read more Very good for the area, great service, nice reuse of the building too, if you are in the area go try it you will like it a lot of the food and desserts are made at the restaurant and will take you even if you don't have reservations too. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Soup

Great local place to dine, will definitely go back. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dis... read more Great local place to dine, will definitely go back. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Salad with Their Home Made Dressing, Soup, Bread Plate Free with Dinner Available During Lunch if Requested, Pecan Chicken, Salads

Dropped by for lunch. We were seated outside on a cloudy, chili, breezy day with nothing but a bottle of water (no glasses) and silverware. We waited 15 minutes... read more Dropped by for lunch. We were seated outside on a cloudy, chili, breezy day with nothing but a bottle of water (no glasses) and silverware. We waited 15 minutes and left. WORST SERVICE EVER!!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Amazing handmade pasta, fantastic staff, and I adore the cozy 6-seat bar with the best craft cocktail bartenders. Don’t forget to try the assorted layer cakes m... read more Amazing handmade pasta, fantastic staff, and I adore the cozy 6-seat bar with the best craft cocktail bartenders. Don’t forget to try the assorted layer cakes made on-site!

Fabulous service! Fabulous food!Thank you for a wonderful birthday!. ? read more Fabulous service! Fabulous food!Thank you for a wonderful birthday!. ?

Friied smoked mozzarella cheese appetizerSweet sausage ravioli with red sauce.Dessert not pictured but the cakes are fantasic with a good variety. read more Friied smoked mozzarella cheese appetizerSweet sausage ravioli with red sauce.Dessert not pictured but the cakes are fantasic with a good variety.

When you spin the wheel of what to eat for dinner tonight? be sure to add Selah to that list! We came here for something new to try based off a referral from my... read more When you spin the wheel of what to eat for dinner tonight? be sure to add Selah to that list! We came here for something new to try based off a referral from my cousin. First off, the atmosphere is quaint and warm yet vibrant at the same time. There is a great mix of old history and new decor. The service was exceptional and the staff all seemed to work very well together!Now onto the stuff that most people actually care about... the food.Appetizers were the meat and cheese plate and the whipped feta with honey. The meat and cheese plate was good, but let 's be honest, it 's a meat and cheese plate. BUT the whipped feta with honey was exceptional! Imagine a honey drizzled cheesecake, minus the whole cake setting.For dinner I got the Niagara Falls Walleye with asparagus and it was cooked perfectly. Sauteed in a brown butter sauce and very flaky yet not crumbly. My wife got the gnocchi and meatballs with ricotta. All of which are make in house! The meatballs are tender yet they don 't disintegrate in the sauce. The gnocchi definitely holds it 's own with a great texture!Dessert was their made in house banana salted caramel cake and the French vanilla cake. Both of which were good but the banana salted caramel stole the show by far.All in all we had a good experience and will be back! A solid 8.2!

Selah Restaurant is truly a hidden gem. The building's history as a former bank adds a unique touch to the dining experience. They even have a large table insid... read more Selah Restaurant is truly a hidden gem. The building's history as a former bank adds a unique touch to the dining experience. They even have a large table inside the vault that can be reserved for special occasions, making it a fun space for private group celebrations. The service is exceptional, which enhances the overall experience. Their dinner menu is delightful, and they offer a selection of homemade cakes displayed right by the entrance. Be sure to treat yourself to a slice of their delectable cake to complement your meal. I absolutely love this place; it’s one of my favorite spots. It’s perfect for couples seeking a romantic ambiance. Additionally, they have a theater room upstairs that hosts dinner theater performances. Overall, this is a 5-star restaurant. As for parking, you can usually find a spot right outside the building, but during busy times, you might need to park on the street or a little further away.