Not Justa Cafe - Stillwater

I've always loved this place for a good **** and breakfast. However my most recent visit is what prompted me to write a review. I had THE most perfect BLT. I chose pumpernickel rye for the bread. The toast, bacon and iceberg lettuce were perfectly crisp and the tomato was delicious. Also, the beer cheese soup....amazing!

As a longtime patron of this place it makes me sad to see how its gone downhill. After being really happy to see it reopen, I've noticed that the quality of the food, the drinks, and the staff have all suffered. After commenting repeatedly on flat soda pop out of the gun I was told it was fine so I started bringing my own. After ordering the haddock fillet (my favorite! one Friday it came burnt because the oil was too hot. For the first time ever I sent it back and got it back exactly the same way. I could work through all of this but the apathy of the new staff was just too much. Breakfast is still good so I will keep coming on the weekend mornings hoping against hope for a change for the better.

We usually really like the food here. Stopped last week and ordered a burger and fries. When the meal got there, the fries were soggy but I ate them. I later realized this was a big mistake as they were most likely not crisp because the oil had probably been turned off after the lunch rush or it was just plain old oil and it made me very sick. I have learned a lesson and will send things back to the kitchen from here on out. Lost my taste for fries for a while. Diner beware!

Love this super cute new version of a dive bar! Very clean! Great place to have a beer, friendly conversation and good service.

Sundays here are great. ****'s. Breakfast. Bar people. Love this place. Good service. Good food.