Casey's - Staples

Pizza, Cheese, Sandwiches

Casey's

Casey's
3.6 / 5 (247 reviews)

Description

At this local gas station and eatery, experiences are varied. While some patrons enjoy the friendly service and unique menu items like the Denver sandwich pizza, others express frustration over the quality and pricing of offerings, particularly the Hawaiian pizza deemed overpriced due to disappointing toppings. Concerns have also been raised about cleanliness outside the establishment and inconsistent food quality, including pizzas that can collapse under their own toppings. However, friendly staff and a generally clean interior have earned this spot some loyal customers, who appreciate the convenience of grabbing a slice along with gas. Overall, opinions are mixed.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Jamison

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 247 reviews
jamison56
30.08.2022

I typically enjoy Casey's in general. I love the variety of Casey's brand food they offer. I only gave it a 4 rating because I had to wait a long time in line and felt like the staff could use some help or at least move more efficiently.

robel-jimmy
30.08.2022

Yesterday at around 1 or 2 pm, my daughter ordered two large pizzas, a side of cheese sticks, and a side of boneless wings. The cheese sticks and wings were great! However, both pizzas had very thin crusts that couldn't hold the toppings, causing them to collapse. My grandkids were disappointed as all the toppings fell off. I will probably avoid ordering pizza from this place in the future.

jeramie05
30.08.2022

The gas pump islands were dirty, trash was scattered on the floor outside, and the cement around the gas pumps appeared to have not been cleaned from spilled fuel.

jamison56
30.08.2022

I often go to casey, for gas, pizza, sub-sandwiches, they have friendly staff and their closeness to me

ned-ryan-1
30.08.2022

We stopped in a couple of nights ago to grab a piece of pizza. It should be noted that not only did they have a piece of pizza they had four different kinds and each piece looked more cheesy and more fresh than the last... The pizza area was top notch..super clean food area.and I think the woman's tag said Heather so thank you for a clean environment and all the awesome Pizza Heather we appreciated it!!! it should also be duly noted, a guy named JD was working at the counter. He was nice and he was super friendly. He answered our questions with no hesitation.. I will be coming back to this location because of the vibe and the positive environment and clean environment that these two brought to the table.. so thank you from someone passing through town..

FAQ

You can also pay for your menus with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.