Reviews
What Jo Anne Loxley likes about Bagels Supreme:
The bagels here are fantastic, and I really enjoy the variety of cream cheese flavors. I usually spend around $50 each time I visit. However, since I was the only customer during my visit, I expected at least a smile from the young woman who served me. Instead, I felt like she was irritated that I was there. I only get to come once or twice a year because I live quite far away, but the customer service could definite... View all feedback.
What Alexy G doesn't like about Bagels Supreme:
The person at the counter informed me that their bagel egg sandwich was made with microwave eggs. I've never encountered that at a bagel shop before! I decided to leave immediately. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
These aren't just the best bagels in town or even the best in New Jersey; they are truly the best bagels (and spreads) on the entire planet! Just a friendly req...
read moreThe bagels are outstanding, especially when paired with cream cheese and nova lox.
The best bagels ever! If you are in the area a must try!
Best bagels in the area. Not many options besides bagels, so know that ahead of time.
The best freshly made bagels in town! I prefer my bagels extra crispy, and they always deliver. The staff is fantastic and the service is wonderful. I've been a...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe bagels here are fantastic, and I really enjoy the variety of cream cheese flavors. I usually spend around $50 each time I visit. However, since I was the on...
read moreThe bagels were stale, and charging an extra $2.50 for veggie cream cheese is unreasonable.
The person at the counter informed me that their bagel egg sandwich was made with microwave eggs. I've never encountered that at a bagel shop before! I decided...
read moreBeen around for years. Large variety of bagels, sandwiches and drinks cold/hot. Friendly service.
The Very Best Bagels in Union County and perhaps the entire State of New Jersey.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe best bagels I’ve had in Jersey! The only other place that came close was in Elmora, Elizabeth, but they've been closed for years. These bagels have that sam...
read moreI've been buying these bagels for 35 years, and I make a 25-minute drive just to get them. They are definitely the best bagels around!
I don’t want to admit it, but the best bagels are made right here in New Jersey! I absolutely love them! They’re freshly made throughout the day. There’s really...
read moreBeen trying to find a decent bagel spot in NJ since moving from NY. Bagel Supreme is it! Best bagels in NJ!
The only bagel my rabbi allows in his synagogue Wed senior day 9.49/doz great value
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more