Poppy Seeds Bagels - South Setauket

The best breakfast sandwiches and bagels in town. Very fast turn out for how busy they are on the weekends.

Bagels are hard and cheap on cream cheeseHad to wait forever for food

Pretty disappointing the change in management made this place severely lacking in being noticed to get a bagel after stating several times in front of people I wasn’t being helped. Foods good but current employees are severely lacking compared to the previous owner and team. Shame really.

The best, freshest bagels around! Always! I got a bagel at noon one day, and it was still super soft and delicious. They make their sandwiches with love! It's always my go to spot, never disappointed!

I have been going toThis bagel store for the last year now theres new people behind the counter seems for the last month or so today i ordered 1 egg white on a roll nothing else on it they rang it up $4.00 omelet+1.50 egg white and i said what how much ? I didnt order no omelet Thats right thats how it works i thought things werent adding up last time i orded there 3 eggwhite turkey and avocado special 8.50 price on board and i remember her charging me 1.50 but thought mabe charge for something else normally spend $24-30 on multiple egg sandwichs NOT ANY MORE RIP ME OFF ONCE ok mistake twice no to many begel stores around to be ripped off !!!!!