Costello's Pizzeria And Wings

Best pizza in Galloway. I just placed my order about 15 minutes ago, it's already hot in my house, fresh and good! Once they forgot my bag of chips with my sub, I let them know and they brought me a bag of chips without problems.

The pizza is great here: Clear, pepperoni, white etc., whatever you get, cut or whole cake is very good. But the Steak Subs are where it is. Probably the best place in Galloway if not the district. But the frits are not so hot. I think they're gonna pack them out of the frit for pickups. You're never as sharp as Pommes. You guys step in and it's 5 stars safe.

The Buffalo chicken pizza is very good, and the wings are also quite solid. You have the buffalo sauce down, sweet and not too hot. Oh, and the pizza slices are pretty big. Only a complaint would have been a strange piece after the taste of the cheese pizza, but it was quite prominent. Otherwise it was pretty good.

I can see how some of the reviewers say that they placed an order, but the place is closed BUT when you read the sign, the arrow guides you where you pick up orders. The girl in the counter was kind. The food was quite delicious for the area had a Margarita pizza, Buffalo wing and a salad.

Used to order frequently from Costellos, specifically the bomboli (always phenomenal), but this time wanted to try the ol buffalo chicken pizza I used to always eat as a kid. This turned out to not be a good idea as the pizza was horrible. Buffalo sauce wasn’t sweet like it usually is and the cheese just fell off the pizza. Literally the entire slice’s cheese just shlopped off as I picked it up. Chicken was old and dry and taste like refrigerator. Will stick to bombolis in the future. Delivery was fast.