Smithtown Bagels

#21 - Mexican - Smithtown, Bagels, Coffee
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Smithtown Bagels

Smithtown Bagels
4.4 / 5 (322 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Smithtown Bagels from Smithtown includes 161 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $7.1. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: User

Images

Smithtown Bagels Outside Smithtown Bagels Food

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 322 reviews

Was User at Smithtown Bagels a mag?
The bagels here are always fresh and the coffee is great. The counter staff is always beautiful and attentive. There is ALWAYS a line out of the door every time I am here, that is a testimony to the quality of food and the kindness of staff. The owner works hard to ensure that everything runs smoothly and they do a great task to keep up with the weekend and vacation haste! I moved from NY and get a frequent delivery... View all feedback.

The bagels here are always fresh and the coffee is great. The counter staff is always beautiful and attentive. There is ALWAYS a line out of the door every time I am here, that is a testimony to the quality of food and the kindness of staff. The owner works hard to ensure that everything runs smoothly and they do a great task to keep up with the weekend and vacation haste! I moved from NY and get a frequent delivery from Bagels to Texas and all here loves them too!

I had two eggs fried sausage mozzarella on a whole wheat battle. It was in a contemporary fashion and it was very tasty. Going coffee was also very good and needed this morning. I'll keep this place on my radar.

Without a doubt, this is the best egg bagel in the entire area, easily outshining 24 Hour Bagels and Brendall's! It's light, fluffy, and crispy, unlike the chewy and juicy offerings from other places.

Fantastic bagel place. the service is so fast, and all employees make you welcome and are definitely happy to talk to you. The Bagels are absolutely amazing. all their cream cheeses are also delicious. the place is much cleaner than any other Bagel places in a few miles radius. I've never been unhappy with a trip to Schmiedtown Bagels.

I relocated here three years ago and visit this restaurant several times a week. The service is exceptional, the food is delicious, and most importantly, the staff is fantastic! Every team member knows my name and often inquires about my daily life, just as they do with many regular customers. My whole family, who aren’t locals, adore the bagels here, so for the past three years, I’ve been treating them to breakfast during every holiday. LOL!

  • Paninis

    Long Islander Panini
    Long Islander Panini
    $12.7
    Brooklyn Paninis
    Brooklyn Paninis
    $12.7
  • Daily Lunch Specials

    Grilled Cheese Daily Lunch Special
    Grilled Cheese Daily Lunch Special
    $10.7
    Gary's Bat Chaser Daily Lunch Special
    Gary's Bat Chaser Daily Lunch Special
    $10.7
    Clife Hanger Daily Lunch Specials
    Clife Hanger Daily Lunch Specials
    $10.7
    Daily Double Daily Lunch Special
    Daily Double Daily Lunch Special
    $10.7

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.