Casey's - Slayton

American, North American, Pizza

Casey's

Casey's
3.5 / 5 (135 reviews)

Description

Casey’s delivers a mixed dining experience, particularly with its pizza. While some patrons rave about the fantastic taste and impeccable service, others report inconsistent quality, citing dry, poorly cut pizzas lacking adequate sauce. Service issues have also been noted, including long wait times and insufficient staffing during busy hours. However, the cleanliness of the establishment and the friendliness of the staff leave a positive impression. Overall, while the atmosphere and some menu items impress, consistency in food preparation and service remains a significant area for improvement at Casey's.

Last update: 16.06.2026 from: Julie

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 135 reviews
julie-d-flower702
24.06.2024

We stopped by for a quick break to refuel and have some drinks. The restrooms and the entire place were clean. As we walked in, the staff at the counter welcomed us warmly. We grabbed a few snacks to go along with our drinks, and the kids particularly loved the tasty pizza.

april-kreel-grass664
24.06.2024

When I visited the restaurant this morning between 9:30 and 10 AM, I found no food in the warmers, and the lights were off, as if they hadn't been turned on yet. I needed to use the restroom, but had to wait quite a while. Eventually, I ended up using the men's restroom after waiting for a long time for the others to become available. It appeared that only one person was handling both the kitchen and the counter during a busy period.

katie
20.05.2024

My boyfriend and I order from Casey's Pizza at least once a week. Unfortunately, every time we do, the pizza is cut awkwardly, tends to be dry, and it seems like there's little effort in ensuring the cheese covers the entire pie. Tonight, we had pizza again, and it had hardly any sauce on it. It’s so disappointing that we’re considering just throwing it away. Slayton Casey's really needs to retrain their kitchen staff.

heather-marie-5
20.05.2024

Slayton Casey's is consistently clean, and the staff is friendly and extremely helpful! The food is always delicious!

jamie-thomazin-eleph
20.05.2024

I recently placed an online order for pizza to pick up at a local restaurant. The website said my order would be ready in 20 minutes, but when I got there, they had no record of it and informed me it would take about an hour to prepare. This has happened to me twice now when ordering online from this restaurant. I recommend they hire someone more skilled with technology or suggest trying a different pizza place, like Domino's.

FAQ

The rooms in the restaurant are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physical limitations.

The place accepts various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.