Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.4 out of 5
Impressive | 223 reviews

What Clarrissa H likes about Citi Island Seafood:
SURPRISED US WHAT I AM! It was hot and so good What a change from the low quality that this door dash and Uber generation has turned the quality of food service into. Over cooked burnt dry and just wrong orders but wow if you like seafood like me this is the PLACE. Well done yall well done. View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Int Restaurants
4.7 ★ from 92 reviews
Daren
19.06.2023 - 10:43

Great food The staff was very nice, only a little understated everything was excellent

Kamren
19.06.2023 - 10:43

I was in Shirley on Iceland today. We were blown away from the tasty of food! The roasted shrimp was so fresh and tasty and the baked Mac and cheese was the bes...

read more
Daren
19.06.2023 - 10:43

Great place great food the waitress is awesome food was amazing, the only thing they need more staff

Adah
19.06.2023 - 10:43

Food is Fresh and tasty. Customer service was Great. Food prepared rather quickly.

Dante
19.06.2023 - 10:43

Good food, good service

Doordash
4.2 ★ from 131 reviews
Clarrissa
28.01.2024 - 15:45

SURPRISED US WHAT I AM! It was hot and so good What a change from the low quality that this door dash and Uber generation has turned the quality of food service...

read more
Sophia
28.01.2024 - 15:45

Food was overcooked and seemed to be days old. Very dry and inedible.

Anne
28.01.2024 - 15:45

Seafood was super fresh and everything was really tasty

Melissa
28.01.2024 - 15:45

I have so many pictures of the dead clams and mussels in the pot about 8 or 9 each . Other than that everything was fine

Facebook
5.0 ★ from 3 reviews
Google
3.9 ★ from 29 reviews
Tripadvisor
4.9 ★ from 2 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Shirley

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Shirley, 924 Montauk Highway, Shirley, 11967, United States Of America
"Great coffee and they sell local honey too"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Shirley, 492 William Floyd Pkwy, 11967, Shirley, United States
"Dirty and old. Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1"
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Farmingville (near Shirley), 623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, United States
"I'm from dallas. I never had that. we have blue bell. this place is so great. I've been here 4 times now. it's like soft serve and a snow cone went on..."
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: East Patchogue (near Shirley), 655-8 Montauk Hwy.NY 11772, East Patchogue, United States
"Everything was delicious and the evening was perfect."
4.8
Menu
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Open Now
City: Lake Ronkonkoma (near Shirley), 239 Hawkins Ave, 11779-4265, Lake Ronkonkoma, United States
"Delicious and healthy. Made a minor mistake on our order today, but took care of it above and beyond. Very classy and proper."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Baiting Hollow (near Shirley), 100 Fox Hill Dr, 11933, Baiting Hollow, US, United States
"Excellent venue for a wedding. One of the best on the northfork."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Centereach (near Shirley), 1370 Middle Country Rd, 11720, Centereach, United States
"Summer staple, love Ralph's !! Everything is delicious"
4.8
Menu
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Open Now
City: Lake Ronkonkoma (near Shirley), 386 Portion Rd, 11779-2356, Lake Ronkonkoma, United States
"Unfortunately, while I love this Carvel, they do business with UberEats who ghosted my order leaving me with no delivery and having to call AmEx on Ub..."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Centereach (near Shirley), 1950 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, USA, 11720-3535, United States
"The Chicken Parmigiana is a masterpiece!!"
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Shirley, 862 Montauk Hwy, 11967, Shirley, United States
"Took the grandchildren! Grandson said best burger ever!!"