Greek's Pizzeria - Shelbyville

We have had Greek's in Noblesville several times and loved it, unfortunately we did not love this particular location. The pizza was about 30 minutes late, over cooked, and had a crazy amount of flour on the crust. We were taking everything on a picnic, so I asked for plates, napkins, and utensils they were out of EVERYTHING except the napkins. I had ordered a salad cost was over $9, so I was expecting a family size salad, but ended up with a very small, smaller than fast food sized salad. I went back to get 2 more (because we had lots of people) and it took another 30 minutes to make the 2 salads. Very disappointing! Will not be returning.

Great service and atmosphere. The pizza reminds me of the pizziaras from the 80's. Very good pizza! I Highly recommend you to visit this place! Cleanliness (5), service (5), food (5).

Just ordered a large pizza. The toppings were so skimpy. I told them light on the sauce, there was no sauce. hardly any cheese the pepperoni was so over cooked it was crispy. Never had crispy pepperoni before. Paid thirty some dollars and wasn’t worth $10.00

Very surprised, I went in with a group of 20 tonight. I seriously thought they would fail but did great. Great food and service.

We've tried this a few times since opening. The pizza is good, however to me, it's just not worth the price.