Randall's - Sheboygan

Burgers, Hamburger, Ice Cream

Randall's

Randall's
3.5 / 5 (26 reviews)

Description

In the heart of Sheboygan, this burger joint offers a blend of homemade flavors and customization, embracing a casual, friendly atmosphere. While many fans praise the delectable Oostburger and tender brats, some diners have voiced concerns over inconsistent service and food quality. Long waits and mismanaged online orders detract from the experience, leading some to recommend competitors like Culver’s instead. Packaging problems have also marred takeout orders, causing spills and dissatisfaction. Despite these drawbacks, loyal patrons continue to appreciate the straightforward menu and friendly staff, hoping for a brighter future as the restaurant faces potential closure.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Lucy

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 26 reviews
indrani28
25.11.2017

We always stop in when visiting the in laws from the Pacific NorthwestOn our first night here, we voted for Randall's.

genevieve58
25.11.2017

Stopped in on a road trip We were looking for a local place vsthe standard off-the-highway options.

dudley-oconner
25.11.2017

I've been coming here since I was a babyLiterally an infantIt's one of those restaurants that have been here forever.

lehner-lucy
14.01.2023

Friendly staff with good simple food. The custard is top notch as well.

kunze-saul
14.01.2023

Eating is always great and especially great today. I remember the old Dutch dairy many years ago and that was always a good memory. I'll charge it five.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.