Images
Contribute
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What A Bcd likes about Geno Nottolini's Pizza:
I absolutely love this place! Their pizza is fantastic, and the mozzarella sticks paired with the marinara sauce are a must-try. Honestly, I could drink that marinara by the gallon—it's truly the best you'll ever find! View all feedback.
What MistahZ doesn't like about Geno Nottolini's Pizza:
I strongly advise against dining here. This is, without a doubt, the worst 'pizza' I have ever had the misfortune of trying, and it's possibly the worst experience I've had at a restaurant overall. It's disappointing because the sides were actually decent—maybe even good—but the 'pizza' I ordered completely overshadowed that with its terrible texture and excessively watery, overly moist toppings. Save your money and... View all feedback.
We are from MN and found this pizza place on Google Maps. I was able to place an online order. Times on Google said they were open from noon to 12:45 AM, their online ordering system allowed order to be submitted. We got an online notification pizza will be ready at 12:30 PM that day. My brother who is also coming for a vacation notified me this business was not open based on a screenshot he shared with me. I tried to call the pizza place three times on Sunday beginning at 12PM to confirm their hours and nobody answered the phone. I called the merchant after getting a text today that our pizza was ready (when we are headed back home) and requested a refund for the amount of pizza plus tip. Manager said no because it was ready on time claiming today was the day for it to be ready when I placed the order on Sunday. She said they are open every day from noon to 12:45AM and she said there was nothing she could do since it was through another merchant the order was put through.
Very expensive. Pizza was cold and little flavor . 48 dollars for a pizza and Garlic bread was not on my plan for a dinner we hardly ate
The food is spectacular. The Chicago Style pizza is my favorite. Maybe the best pizza in Sheboygan? Definitely the most underrated. They also have a lot of other things besides pizza. Their Rick's special beef sandwich is fantastic, they have very good wings, and a lots of other things I haven't tried yet. This may be my favorite restaurant in town.
We have given this place three chances. First two times the order was wrong, and it took over 30 minutes to get ahold of anyone to get anything fixed. At that point, with upset kids what do you do? Don?t bother. Third time, took my money and canceled my order. Kind feels like theft here bud. Definitely not worth the time
On a positive note, I had a perfect ravioli meal a week ago, so I know the kitchen has potential. It seems like there might be an issue with one particular cook who needs to be more attentive. I'm uncertain about continuing to order from here if the quality isn’t consistent. It’s a shame because when the food is cooked well, it’s really enjoyable.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
